Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Friday, Sep 19, 2003

News
Features
Stocks
Port Info
Archives

Group Sites

Opinion - Cotton
Industry & Economy - Modernisation


Is modernisation of TN's ginneries viable?

M. B. Lal
K. R. K. Iyer

THE Government of India offers subsidy of up to Rs 27 lakh to every newly set up or modernised composite ginning and pressing (G&P) factory through Mini Mission IV of the Technology Mission on Cotton (TMC), a scheme launched in February 2000. The TMC, which will operate for eight years till 2006-07, intends to cover 500 G&P units, of which 262 have so far been taken up. While 154 projects have been completed, 50 more will be ready by October-November 2007.

Tamil Nadu remains aloof

Most of the 262 factories under the scheme are from Gujarat (153), Maharashtra (76) and Madhya Pradesh (19). There are very few entries from the southern and northern States. Tamil Nadu is yet to open account with TMC. The reluctance of Tamil Nadu ginners is attributable to their belief that large units with 24 double roller (DR) machines — a TMC requirement — will not make profits, as cotton production in the State is very low.

It is argued that in Tamil Nadu, there are as many as 360 ginneries to process five lakh bales of cotton, each unit turning out an average of only 1,400 bales annually. At present, most of the ginneries are functioning with four-12 DR gins, and it is said that expansion to 24 DRs is not economically viable.

The above argument is fallacious as the TMC does not expect all the 360 factories of Tamil Nadu to modernise. The TMC's objective is to ensure that factories are well equipped with modern machines and good infrastructure, and have a minimum production rate of 8 bales per hour which demands 24 DR gins of normal size. Tiny units producing trashy and contaminated cotton as well as units that do pressing work alone will be incompatible with a quality-driven raw material market for textiles and will have to wind up after 2004.

There is a suggestion from the southern ginning community that the TMC norms should be altered by permitting 12 machines instead of insisting on 24 DRs to modernise the small units of Tamil Nadu at a minimal cost. This suggestion, however, is unacceptable for the following reasons:

  • The Central Government norms cannot be diluted to suit a section of beneficiaries in one or two States. Such a step would be discriminatory, considering that there are small ginneries in all States.

  • Modernised ginneries of 12 gins will not be economically viable as the cost of bale press and automatic conveyors, which together constitute 45-50 per cent of the modernisation cost, will not be different from that for a 24 DR gin factory.

  • It is not the TMC's intention to modernise all the existing factories regardless of their size. As already pointed out, modernisation through the TMC will be restricted to 500 ginning units out of the 4,000 units existing in the country today. Redundant ones are expected to close down as a matter of course.

    G&P units required in Tamil Nadu

    For the present cotton production level in Tamil Nadu, the TMC prescribes about 30-35 standard-sized ginneries. Cluster centres, such as Avinashi, Tirupur, Theni and Rajapalayam, with 25-45 tiny units each can afford to have four-six ginneries of standard size. All such ginneries will receive plenty of cotton for processing and will carry out profitable ginning.

    Low-cost modernisation for Tamil Nadu ginneries

    Considering the backwardness of the Tamil Nadu ginning industry and its traditional mindset and apprehensions, the TMC will advise the ginneries to opt for low cost machinery and infrastructure that keeps investment within affordable limits. It is possible to restrict the level of sophistication of machines whereby the capital cost of a unit can be reduced without compromising on cotton quality.

    One such model has been prepared by the TMC Cell whose economics work out to be attractive as shown in Tables 1, 2 and 3.

    The low cost composite G&P unit will involve an investment of Rs 120 lakh, of which the TMC will reimburse Rs 27 lakh as subsidy. The net investment will be only Rs 93 lakh.

    Labour cost (Table 1) will work out to Rs 44 per bale regardless of the quantity of cotton available for processing. The selection of machines with low degree of sophistication will not only reduce investment, but also involve low electricity consumption whereby the power cost can be limited to Rs 65 per bale compared to about Rs 100 required in ginneries going in for high-level modernisation. The total processing expenditure in a low-cost unit works out to Rs 239 per bale.

    The capital cost (Table 2) comprising interest on investment at 13 per cent and depreciation at 12 per cent comes to Rs 23.3. This cost is unrelated to the number of bales processed in the factory.

    The net returns likely from the low-cost G & P unit which depends on the number of bales actually processed is given in Table 3.

    A factory that receives enough cotton to process 20,000 bales will earn a net profit close to Rs 38 lakh. With reduced business, the profit goes down. Even with 10,000 bales a profit of over Rs 7 lakh appears quite probable.

    Additional benefits

    The profitability worked out above applies to ginners undertaking job work. Those who also carry out their own cotton business are able to derive several additional benefits from modernisation. With machines taking the role of workers, the production rate in ginning is high, leading to increased earnings. Many factory owners are getting premiums ranging from Rs 150 to Rs 500 per bale for clean cotton processed in modernised units.

    Some ginners are happy to earn reputation as suppliers of clean cotton whereby bales get sold as soon as they are made, speeding up the turnover and raising profits. Other ginners, with elite mills now in their clientele, regard assured payment as the best reward for modernisation.

    With high storage capacities generated through the TMC support, some ginneries are able to work for more number of days in the season, making higher profits.

    Looking ahead

    From the above analysis it follows that modernisation of ginneries is, indeed, a viable proposition, and that ginners of Tamil Nadu should resolve to set up a few new units particularly in the cluster centres.

    (The authors are respectively Adviser, Technology Mission on Cotton (MMs III & IV), Mumbai and Consultant, Technology Mission on Cotton, Mumbai.)

    Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication

  • Stories in this Section
    Powering a tariff policy


    Back to the future — Q4 to look like Q2
    US' concern over job outsourcing — Old-world style protectionism
    China: The Gen-next export destination?
    Mutual funds — The importance of hedging short-term
    Keep off neocons
    Is modernisation of TN's ginneries viable?
    Indian Railways: Time to improve standards
    Helping the aged
    Price collapse
    HPCL, BPCL sell-off


    The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
    Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | The Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | Home |

    Copyright © 2003, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line