Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Thursday, Jun 06, 2002

Port Info

Group Sites

Industry & Economy - Pharmaceuticals

Patents Bill needs surgery, say pharma MNCs

Our Bureau

MUMBAI, June 5

POST the second amendment in the Patents Bill, multinational pharma companies feel that with the Bill being inconsistent with the TRIPs specifications, a third amendment before January 1, 2005 could well be under way.

Mr Ranjit Shahani, President, Organisation of Pharmaceutical Producers of India (OPPI), said that a number of provisions in the Bill are inconsistent with the minimum international standards. "The legislation does little to change the basic deficiencies underlying the 1970 law and dilutes the Intellectual Property protection to the detriment of the patent holder.''

India has to comply with the TRIPs agreement from January 1, 2005 and implement the product patent as described in the agreement.

According to Dr Prabhudda Ganguly, Patent Attorney, Vision-IPR, "There are lot of loopholes in the second amendment in the patent Bill. The key issues of debate include the grating of patents in all areas of technologies and reversal of burden of proof. A third amendment could be under way looking at the present structure of the second amendment patent Bill.''

The other main concern is the issue of compulsory licensing. "Compulsory licensing provisions should not be widened. It is desirable to define the process of declaring national emergency and also prescribe the authorities empowered to do so. This will reduce any ambiguity and will make the whole process transparent,'' Mr Shahani said.

Problems in compulsory licensing are compounded by the issue of remuneration of the patentee. Says Ms Krishnan Sarma, Corporate Law Group and an expert on patent law: "Section 90 (1) (i) of the Bill provides that the terms of the licence are to be set so as to provide remuneration to the patent owner that is reasonable. There is no clarity as to what reasonable is and who will ascertain it.''

Dr Ganguly suggested that an integrated single window national IPR commission should be constituted.

Send this article to Friends by E-Mail

Stories in this Section
More judges, courts `will stave off lawlessness'

`Low-quality employment is problem not joblessness'
IBRD aid for Gujarat, Karnataka
A new beginning
Call for preservation of AP mangroves forests
Karnataka to export milk, sugar to Lanka
Patents Bill needs surgery, say pharma MNCs
New power tariff policy within 3 months: Prabhu
Power tariff hike in Kerala `inevitable'
Doubts over DVC capacity augmentation programme
NLC exceeds April generation target
KERC directive to KPTCL
Kerala: Advisory councils for power complaints
AIMO opposes Haryana levy
`Textile sector showing signs of recovery'
World Bank aid for Karnataka rural water management project
Proposal for DD Metro to become satellite channel
Aluminium sector sets ingot output target at 7.2 l.t.
Notebook makers run for cover
Tirupur exporters seek board to boost textiles
ISRO expanding facilities
ISRO scouts for hardware vendors
GSLV Mark 3 gets approval
Nalco: ABN-Amro Rothschild to be advisor, book runner
Eco-savvy women's self-help groups
Fair by disabled at Chennai
Interaction with BSNL official
Hyderabad Engagements
Some tax payers allowed to use old Saral form
Kerala: No fall in tourist arrivals
Steps to check money laundering
Market integrity: RBI expert group submits report

The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | The Sportstar | Frontline | Home |

Copyright 2002, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line