Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Friday, Jul 09, 2004

Cross Currency

Group Sites

Industry & Economy - Budget
Markets - Mutual Funds

Mutual funds — Odds stacked against debt funds

Aarati Krishnan

BY OFFERING significant concessions on capital gains tax for securities traded on the stock exchanges, Budget 2004 appears to have made direct investing an attractive option relative to investments routed through mutual funds.

Investors in equity mutual funds may still have reason to cheer Budget 2004, as dividends paid out by these funds continue to be exempt from tax. But the budget proposals may significantly erode the attractions of debt-oriented mutual funds in relation to assured-return savings options.

Proposals for equity funds:

Equity funds have once again been exempt from dividend distribution tax. Equity funds were exempt from dividend distribution tax in 2003-04, but this exemption lapsed on March 31 2004. Investors can now take home tax-free dividends from equity funds for this year as well.

Though capital gains tax has been pruned; this is applicable only to "securities transacted through stock exchanges". When you invest directly in stocks, you may now have to pay only 10 per cent as short term capital gains tax, while long term capital gains is totally exempt from tax.

In contrast, if you route the investments through an equity fund, you may have to shell out long term capital gains tax at 10 per cent. Short term capital gains, on units held for less than a year, will be subject to your marginal rate of tax, which may range between 10 and 30 per cent.

This seems to weaken the case for routing your investments through equity funds. But quite a few equity funds have delivered substantially higher returns when compared to the stock markets over a five-year period. So if you plan to invest for the long term, weigh the higher tax incidence on equity funds, against the value added by the fund manager when you decide between the two.

The best way to reduce tax incidence on your equity fund investments would be to stick to the dividend option. That way, you will be able to periodically encash the returns that your fund earns, in the form of tax-free dividends.

Equity and debt funds can no longer be used for dividend or bonus stripping as both loopholes have been effectively plugged.

If you enter a fund prior to its dividend date, you now have to stay in for at least nine months before you exit.

The turnover tax of 0.15 per cent imposed on all transactions on securities, may peg up transaction costs for equity funds. Since most equity funds churn their portfolios quite frequently, the cascading impact on the expense ratios of funds may be high. Not an issue as long as equity funds outperform their benchmarks by hefty margins; but could begin to hurt if the gap narrows. Higher transaction costs could peg up tracking error for passively managed index funds.

Proposals for debt funds

The Budget proposes to tax dividend distributions from debt funds at different rates based on the identity of the investor. Fund houses will continue to pay distribution tax of 12.5 per cent on dividends paid to individuals. But the distribution tax will be at 20 per cent if paid to others (read corporates). This proposal is welcome in theory. It may force fund houses to segregate schemes into different plans for corporate and retail investors. Only then can differential taxes be imposed on the two sets of investors. Such segregation will help retail investors as they will no longer be subject to the volatile flows and the associated costs that results from treasury flows into debt funds.

But as this differential tax is proposed only for dividend options, in practice, corporates may simply switch their investments from the dividend to the growth options of debt funds.

Returns on the growth option, which are reckoned as capital gains, are proposed to be taxed at the same rate both for corporate and individual investors.

Like with equity funds, direct investments in bonds will be more tax-efficient than investing through debt funds, as transactions in debt fund units will continue to be subject to the earlier rates of capital gains tax, while capital gains tax has been cut for bonds traded through the exchanges.

The growth option may be more tax-efficient than the dividend option for individual investors in debt funds, provided you plan to hold for over a year.

The proposal to levy a 0.15 per cent turnover tax on all transactions in securities seems to include transactions in bonds.

These transaction costs can have a significant impact on bond fund returns. Due to volatile corporate flows, bond funds suffer a significant churn on their portfolios and transaction costs will have to be borne every time the fund puts through a transaction.

Bond fund returns have hovered in the 4-5 per cent range over the past year. If portfolio turnover is high, the impact of transaction costs can be quite sizeable.

More Stories on : Budget | Mutual Funds

Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication :: Printer Friendly Page

Stories in this Section
More bank finance for stock brokers

`Budget is not inflationary' — Transaction tax no impediment to stock market activities
Chidambaram plays the popular tune — Tax breaks for farm sector and lower middle class
Thumbs down by markets
Service tax on transport intermediaries hailed
Adopting the Keynesian route
FDI push on telecom
Shipping industry says `ahoy!'
Mutual funds — Odds stacked against debt funds
Tonnage tax at last for a smooth sailing
Focus on rural housing; tax rebates to stay
Banking on industrial growth
IIG to beef up infrastructure
ONGC, GAIL to carry the can
A rural slant
Power on `line
Govt to facilitate crop diversification
A bitter pill, says pharma sector
Chaos after the wait
At your service, tax!
A progressive budget
Striking a balance
Spurring investments
Continuance of economic reforms
Catch My Point!
Mixed response from India Inc
Move to drop Cenvat may pep up yarn market
'Market pessimism to end soon'
Steps initiated to integrate stock, commodity markets
FDI in aviation capped at 49% — Buying of aircraft to attract tax
Toyota to set up R&D centre in India
0.15 per cent tax to be levied on securities transactions
SPV for Sethusamudram canal project
Insurance FDI limit raised to 49 pc
IDBI gets Rs 9,000 cr to turn zero NPA
In coalition company
Captains of industry give Budget proposals a cautious welcome
Shifting gears
Turnover tax may spook capital gains
RBI sees no Budget trigger for change in rate, inflation outlook
Views from the bottom of a coffee cup
Customs duty cut on metals: Major price impact unlikely
Coop sugar sector needs tax holiday
Water bodies renovation innovative
Transaction tax a dampener: FISE
Modest hike in Central Plan outlays in real terms
Nothing much to glow about
Smooth ride for tractors
No excise duty on dairy machinery
The jam in the Budget
Disinvestment, reborn
Disappointing delivery
Little to build on
Right thrust on crop diversification
Oil and gas — Slickly left alone
3 key areas targeted for 24.6% revenue mop-up
Industry divided on price drop
A taxing scenario for media
Personal finance: Thrust to direct equity investing
A cess to educate
`Back-to-basics' theme
A `neutral-to-negative' exercise: MFs
A mixed bag
Little more buoyant now
Prices static? Not for long
FDI limit hike has insurers smiling — Service tax on risk premium for life cover is a dampener
`More clarity on turnover tax needed'
Sewing up the competition
A lot to cheer about
Turnover tax seen as a blip
Rural sops to get FMCGs going
May impact trading volume: market players
`VAT by 2005, a step in right direction'
Your dream car to become dearer
A limited first step
Consolidation vital
Slip into khadi and morph into a geek
Hindujas interested in desalination project proposal
Budget fails to impress CETMA
`Bold decisions taken on foreign investments'
No impact on gold market; platinum prices may fall
FIPB to fly with clipped wings
Cap for SSI loans raised to Rs 1 cr
A bitter-sweet pill for vegoil sector
Assurance to States on VAT compensation
Service tax hiked to 10 pc; list expanded
An effort to reflect mandate for change
New deal for farmers; more funds for States
Stress on moderation, stability in tax rates
Textiles woven in style
More services annexed at a higher rate
VAT full of promises
Watch out as the government shifts gears and piggybacks
No luck if you cross a `lakh'
Tax admin: Reforms kept in arrears
`No clear theme in the Budget' — Mr Yashwant Sinha, former Finance Minister

The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | The Hindu Images | Home |

Copyright 2004, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line