The Hindu Business Line : Pause and reflect

The Left had never had it so good as when it was extending outside support to the UPA Government. It used to good purpose its political clout acquired by virtue of its numerical strength (60) in the Lok Sabha and carried out the quadruple functions of storm-signal, sounding board, moderator and prompter of deeper reflection on serious issues impinging on national interest. By and large, the Government as well as the nation benefited from the “pause and reflect” button that the Left pressed from time to time.

There were, of course, sections of opinion which believed that the Left could do no right and was swayed by considerations antithetical to India’s ultimate interest. It may well be that at one time India’s Left ideologues regarded the Soviet Union and China as the models for emulation.

However, any person who has dispassionately studied the Left’s stand on national and international issues since the mid-1960s, is bound to be impressed by its sensible approach reflective of its concern for national interest. The strongest suit of the Left is the austere lifestyle of most of its members, in contrast to the five-star ostentation of members of the other parties.

On the nuclear deal, the Left parties have, from the very beginning, been the one political combine that had been far-seeing in alerting the UPA Government about its hidden booby-traps.

They have been right in their reading of the Hyde Act as a possible source of trouble for the functional autonomy of the Government in respect of its strategic atomic energy development programme and the exercise of its sovereign powers in the internal and external affairs.

The Government had been not only wrong but had unbecomingly continued to resort to casuistry in feeding the people with misleading hogwash, such as the Hyde Act being a US domestic legislation and having nothing to do with the 123 Agreement. Sadly, though, the fatigue of the protracted course of the discussions between the UPA and the Left parties for more than a year seems to have left them flustered, resulting in a series of moves on their part that are not in consonance with either their own, or the country’s, interest.

One credited them with enough political savvy to recognise that this was precisely the time for them to show patience without seeming to tighten the screws on the Government beyond endurance.

Doors slammed shut

Particularly in a situation made alarming by inflation with the added threat of sky-rocketing oil prices eating into economic gains and reversing the progress so far made, it was not wise for the Left to look like pulling the rug from under the feet of the Government on an issue that is not only outlandish (as far as the people at large are concerned) but has been simmering for as long as four years.

The Left also breached the cardinal principle of the art and science of negotiations by slamming the doors shut without an escape latch for keeping the parleys going.

For instance, it could have justifiably asked for full details of the India-specific safeguards worked out with the IAEA and time to examine them. Or, it could have asked the Government to secure an undertaking from the US that it would desist from invoking the objectionable provisions of the Hyde Act and the 123 Agreement.

Nobody would have faulted it if these steps put off operationalising of the deal and getting the US Congressional approval for the 123 Agreement. All the confusion, political instability and economic backsliding could have been avoided. On the whole, the Left has overplayed its hand and needlessly thrown the nation into turmoil, besides finding itself outmanoeuvred.

B. S. RAGHAVAN

Related Stories:
Is the Govt skilfully cornering the Left?
Having the deal and saving the Government
Impasse on nuclear deal continues

More Stories on : Power | Politics | Offhand

Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication :: Printer Friendly Page

Stories in this Section
Allahabad HC rejects Bajaj’s plea on cane price issue

Nations under growing pressure to cut energy intake

Fundamental reorganisation of PSUs needed: Jairam Ramesh

Pause and reflect

Pollachi college ties up with TVS for diploma course

Bangalore real estate: Buyers hesitant, expect prices to fall

Gold may test resistance

PM to take up fuel price issue, need for action plan at G8 meet

Nabard workshop on rural biz hubs

Ministry concern over dip in traditional sector exports