Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Sunday, Jan 19, 2003

Investment World
Features
Stocks
Port Info
Archives

Group Sites

Investment World - Stocks
Markets - Recommendation
Info-Tech - Stocks


Mastek: Sell

Suresh Krishnamurthy

SHAREHOLDERS of Mastek can consider reducing their exposure. The stock now trades at a price-to-earnings multiple of around 13 times its per share earnings for the 12-month period ended December 2002. This is high, considering that the guidance for earnings growth in the next six months may be poor.

If the business conditions for software companies improve significantly, Mastek will be able to exceed its earnings growth target. However, even then, the stock will only perform in line with other leading software stocks. In this backdrop, investors can offload their holdings now and contemplate re-entry when valuations decline.

Suitability: The risks involved in investing in stocks of growth companies is relatively high because of the uncertainty over earnings growth rates. This is applicable for Mastek also.

Modest growth

In terms of quarter-on-quarter performance, Mastek's performance of around 6.5 per cent growth in group revenues and earnings is modest. This reflects the difficulties faced by mid-size IT companies in recording double-digit sequential revenue growth due to their inability to pitch for larger size projects.

Significant developments for Mastek in the quarter-ended December 2002 were:

  • Increase in contribution from the US markets; revenues from the US recorded a growth rate of over 50 per cent;

  • Noticeable decline in contribution from Europe;

  • Sharp rise in depreciation costs limits profit growth even as operating expenses growth slowed down;

    Operating cash inflows registered sharp growth.

    The contribution to revenues from the US was the only factor that enabled Mastek report growth in revenues and earnings for the quarter ended December 2002.

    The more than 50 per cent revenue growth over the quarter ended September 2002 helped US operations (which recorded losses in the July-September quarter) swing back into profitability.

    This compensated for the decline in profitability of all other segments, including that of the joint venture with Deloitte Consulting. Profits from the UK operations — major contributor to the bottomline in the year ended June 2002 — fell 25 per cent.

    Interestingly, Mastek was able to restrict growth in operating expenses vis-à-vis revenues. Gross profits rose 12.2 per cent, reflecting the less-than-proportional rise in operating expenses. However, the sharp jump in depreciation costs, mainly because of investments in offshore infrastructure facilities, pulled down profit growth.

    Promisingly, operating cash flows recorded a sizeable growth during the quarter, aided by lower growth in operating expenses and control over debtors.

    Cash on hand with Mastek at Rs 74 crore is now around 52 per cent of its net worth. How the cash is used will also have a significant bearing on the valuation accorded to Mastek.

    Low growth ahead

    Mastek has also revised its earnings guidance for the year-ended June 2003 to between Rs 64-68 crore.

    This is a wide range, given that Mastek recorded profits of Rs 31.51 crore in the first half ended December 2002. Sequential earnings growth guidance is between 3 per cent and 16 per cent.

    Still, there is reason to believe that the earnings growth will be at the lower end of the indicated target band. This is because of the challenges faced by mid-size companies such as Mastek, which have to be contend with relatively modest growth. Only large companies appear to be in a position to tap the potential offered by offshore contracts.

    Moreover, even if Mastek remains successful and is able to notch double-digit quarter-on-quarter revenue growth, it is only likely to be volume-driven.

    In other words, margins may remain under pressure and the profit growth restricted. Given this backdrop, the price-to-earnings multiple of nearly 13 appears high.

    Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication

  • Stories in this Section
    Skol Breweries: Accept


    Syngenta India: Accept
    Toyota Corolla: Style, speed and safety
    Interest rate cuts, debt restructuring — The pay-off for companies
    What retail trading in G-secs means
    Debt market — Striking the right notes
    Exchange traded funds: Are they for you?
    Zurich India Equity: Invest
    HDFC Tax Plan: Invest
    UTI G-Sec shuns State Govt securities
    Does success breed complacence?
    What is tracking error risk?
    IL&FS Bond Fund Short-term Plan: Invest
    Alliance MIP: Sell
    PNB Gilts: Book Profits
    Asahi India Safety Glass: Safe bet
    Shree Cement: Hold/Buy (High Risk)
    Asian Paints: Hold/Buy on declines
    Mastek: Sell
    Hero Honda: Book Profits
    Birla Sun Life Endowment Plan: Flexi Save Plus
    OM Kotak's new retirement policies
    Nirvana from Tata AIG
    Birla's waiver of premium
    Sukhjeevan in deep-freeze
    Outlook remains bleak
    Further uptrend in Jindal Iron
    Nasdaq at crucial juncture
    Ranbaxy perks up on improved earnings
    Retail debt market
    Bonds likely to remain bid
    Derivatives set to vary
    Dreary bout
    Options guide
    Futures guide
    ICICI Bank: Higher yields than on term deposits
    Debit card from Dena Bank
    Can Fin Homes: Well-sheltered
    `The kidswear market is worth Rs 500 crore' — Mr Govind Mirchandani, CEO and MD, Personality Ltd.
    PPF maturity and refund claims
    House property: How to compute income
    House property deductions
    Television Eighteen: Subscribe


    The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
    Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | The Sportstar | Frontline | Home |

    Copyright © 2003, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line