Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Sunday, Sep 21, 2003

Investment World
Features
Stocks
Port Info
Archives

Group Sites

Investment World - Insight
Markets - Stocks


A market high on drugs

Nath Balakrishnan

STOCK prices of pharmaceutical companies have had a scorching run over the past nine months, with 25 prominent players in different segments collectively registering a 78 per cent value increase in this period. The price rally has not been confined to blue-chip and large-cap stocks such as Ranbaxy, Dr Reddy's or GlaxoSmithKline.

The uptrend has been secular, encompassing stocks across both the mid-cap and small-cap categories, including Aurobindo Pharma, Lupin Labs, Divi's Labs, Matrix Labs and Elder Pharma.

Many factors explain this rally. For the MNC majors in the industry, the prospect of a global shift to the product patent regime from January 1, 2005 should open up newer growth avenues. For the homespun drug majors it is the opening up of the generic market in the US that holds out an export opportunity and, hence, greater profits.

And outsourcing opportunities in both the manufacturing and research domains sort of complete the picture. The accompanying piece provides pointers on what action investors need to take on specific stocks.

In addition to sector-specific events, another key driver of stock prices is liquidity.

With frontline IT companies, which held centre-stage with a sharp run-up in prices in late 2001 and 2002 in spite of the tech meltdown in the US, issuing none-too-attractive earnings guidance, it is only natural to expect investors to park their funds in sectors such as pharma, characterised by relatively more stable revenue and earnings streams.

The returns that pharma stocks have generated for the period under consideration show that investors who placed their faith on the sector have been more than amply rewarded. To understand the price performance of pharma stocks since January 1, 2003, they were divided into five clusters: MNC stocks, large-cap Indian pharma stocks, mid-cap diversified stocks, mid-cap bulk drug stocks and small-caps.

The pharma MNCs, which posted the lowest gain of 30 per cent among the five clusters, still outperformed the Sensex, which delivered returns of 26 per cent in the same time period.

The other clusters too significantly outperformed the Sensex, with the mid-cap bulk drug segment posting a return of 270 per cent, the highest among all clusters. For the constituents of each of the clusters, holding period returns for each and the rank of each cluster on the parameter of risk-adjusted return, see accompanying graphic.

MNC re-rating triggers

The convergence of a combination of factors has been responsible for the sharp re-rating of pharma MNCs over the past nine months:

  • First off the re-rating block were the MNC stocks. The extent of the re-rating can be gauged from the fact that MNC majors significantly outperformed their Indian peers in the first five months of this calendar year, with stocks such as Glaxo, Aventis and Pfizer leading the charge.

  • With India recognising only process patents on drugs, these stocks had been at the receiving end of an assault by their Indian counterparts, which specialised in launching copycat versions of patented drugs at a fraction of the original price.

    However, with India set to make the transition to a product patent regime from January 1, 2005, the MNCs have come back with a bang, after languishing for much of the past three years.

    The new regime will provide adequate protection to the original patent-holder and will deter the cheaper imitations in the domestic market. This has led to expectations of MNC majors slowly unveiling new products, drawn from their global parent's pipeline.

  • The other trigger, especially for the MNCs, has been the expectation that the number of drugs that are under price control will be reduced from 75 to about 40. Most MNC players have a sizeable share of their product portfolio under price control, and relaxation in this area would give them the latitude to offer their drugs at market-determined prices.

  • The market has also taken cognisance of specific action taken by companies aimed at improving their bottomlines. For instance, in GlaxoSmithKline, the company undertook a restructuring exercise that focussed on cost-cutting.

    This has provided a fillip to both operating margins as well as earnings. In Aventis, a sharp focus on its key brands addressing the cardio-vascular segment resulted in earnings growing by over 20 per cent in the April-June quarter.

    The other path to growth

    With pharma MNCs training their guns on the Indian market, home-bred companies have adopted exactly the opposite strategy: they have been targeting regulated markets such as the US and Europe in their quest for revenue growth and better profitability.

    Launching products in regulated markets is a protracted process, with companies having to obtain a clutch of approvals from the authorities concerned. But it is worth the effort, as realisations in such markets are superior to those in the domestic market.

    Frontline Indian companies such as Ranbaxy and Dr Reddy's have increasingly become export-oriented. Ranbaxy derives about a third of its revenues from export markets; in Dr Reddy's, the figure is at about 65 per cent.

    Their export drive has received a further boost with the opening up of the generics (drugs going off patent) market in the US, with drugs worth $40 billion expected to go off patent in the next few years. If this was not good news enough, regulators in the US decided to facilitate faster entry of generics into their market, owing to pressure from healthcare authorities to reduce costs.

    However, going forward, it is only the frontline companies that can capitalise on this opportunity. For one, high costs are involved in going through the process of securing regulatory approval for a launch in the US.

    If the launch of a drug calls for litigation in American courts (as in the case of a Para-IV filing, under which a company challenges an existing patent), the costs could run into millions of dollars.

    Therefore, a company's financial muscle would play as pivotal a role as its strengths in analytical chemistry. Companies such as Dr Reddy's and Ranbaxy are better placed than their peers to make sustained efforts at securing market access for a variety of generics that could provide critical revenue mass.

    Outsourcing opportunity

    A strategy aimed at launching formulations (drugs in finished form) through a patent challenge is a high-risk, high-return one; companies such as Dr Reddy's and Ranbaxy have demonstrated recently that the financial upside with such launches can be immense.

    Bulk drug players such as the Hyderabad-based trio of Divi's Labs, Matrix Labs and Aurobindo Pharma, and the Chennai-based Shasun Chemicals have focussed their efforts on supply of bulk drugs (which go into the final formulation) to generic players.

    As generic players target the US market, they will be looking at those suppliers who are not only competitive on price but can also develop products using processes that are non-patent-infringing. Indian bulk drug players provide them both the benefits.

    Admittedly, being a supplier of only bulk drugs might not be as financially lucrative as getting to launch the formulation itself in a regulated market. But once deals are struck with generic manufacturers, they tend to be typically long-term, and guarantee a steady revenue stream.

    Further, in such supplies, pure bulk drug plays (those that do not have a portfolio of formulations) might hold an edge over their counterparts that are into both bulk as well as formulations.

    The reason: Generic players are more comfortable with sourcing bulk from a player that they know for certain will not launch a formulation with the same ingredient.

    For instance, Teva (a leading generic player from Israel) might prefer to source bulk from, say, either Divi's or Matrix, rather than Dr Reddy's. They would prefer to collaborate with only those companies that they believe will not metamorphose into competitors (which Ranbaxy or Dr Reddy's might) in course of time. The outsourcing opportunity is not confined to manufacturing alone; undertaking contract research as well as conducting clinical trials for molecules in the testing stage are areas that hold out promise.

    As global pharma majors focus on their efforts on bringing a new molecule into the market in the shortest possible time-frame, associated activities such as testing would be farmed out. With several diseases of wide-ranging nature being prevalent in India, it also provides a conducive environment for clinical trials to be conducted.

    Stocks such as Suven Pharma and Vimta Labs, which specialise in the contract research and clinical trials respectively, have seen their stocks sizzle, with the latter's price posting close to a four-fold jump in 2003. And those such as Elder Pharma and Neuland Labs, representing small-cap companies, have notched up impressive gains in the ongoing rally.

    Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication

  • Stories in this Section
    Obstacles to good financial reporting


    Godavari Fertilisers: Take the market route
    Medium-sized software companies — Programming a revival
    Evolving business models
    Mapping the risks
    A market high on drugs
    Pharma Stocks: Bounty of good returns
    Expectations `peg' values higher
    Sterlite Industries: Shifting plans, confusing signals
    HPCL/BPCL privatisation — The SC verdict and after
    Franklin India Internet Opportunities: Pare exposures and switch
    Prudential ICICI Income Plan: Invest
    Sundaram Mid-Cap: Pare exposures
    Magnum FMCG Fund: Pare exposures
    L&T: Cash in on the uptrend
    Carborundum Univ: A good value play
    Canara Bank: Buy
    Chettinad Cement: Sell
    Centurion Bank: Pare exposures
    Concor: Buy
    Dredging Corporation: Buy
    Pare exposures in M&M
    Weakness may persist on indices
    Query corner
    Questions `N' Auto
    New housing loan norms for Central staff
    Aviva's EasyLife Plus
    Of chaos and complexity
    Up `N' Down the Street
    Positive undertone prevails
    Using Futures/Options
    Options guide
    Futures guide
    RBI caps interest rates on NRE deposits
    Corporation bank too cuts NRE deposit rates
    Bonds remain biddish
    For motorists... Filling fuel is now on the cards, literally
    Saw Pipes: Power in the pipeline
    VRS optees are eligible for 89(1) relief
    TCM: Unattractive
    Philips India launches new mobile phone
    Hero Honda rolls out `Passion Plus'


    The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
    Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | The Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | Home |

    Copyright © 2003, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line