SEARCH

US Fed: An enigma wrapped in mystery

print   ·  

S. GURUMURTHY

The US Fed, which is the de facto central bank of the world, is an enigmatic institution whose origins are shrouded in mystery. Its shareholding pattern remains a secret. The US Government has only marginal control over it. Given the Fed’s influence on the world economy, it is imperative to have a global watch on its policies and actions, says S. GURUMURTHY.

The US Federal Reserve System “formulates policies that shape” and are shaped by “international developments”. The Fed and international economy “influence each other”.

“Any policy move” of the Fed “influences” and is influenced by international development. This is how the central bank of US stakes claims about its global status and influence in its document “Federal Reserve in International Sphere”.

The Fed’s is no empty claim. No policy statement is needed, a TV byte from it is enough, to shape global developments. Example: Mr Alan Greenspan brought down the Nikkei index by 3.2 per cent on a single day (December 6, 1996) with his remark of “irrational exuberance” suggesting that Japanese stocks were over-valued.

But when the Fed influences the world does it function in global interest? On the contrary, Fed’s actions, the very document claims, “are designed to attain the basic objectives of US economy”. Not global economy! Yet, surprisingly, there has been no significant global watch over this institution or its policies and actions.

Global watch

There are other reasons why global watch over US Fed is inevitable. Look at the ownership of other three major central banks. Germany’s Bundesbank and UK’s Bank of England are fully state-owned. Majority, that is 55 per cent, of Bank of Japan’s stocks is held by Japanese government.

As a central bank performs the vital seigniorial function of printing currency, all central banks are invariably state owned.

The US fed, in contrast, is neither public nor private. As some one put it, it is “a cartel of private banks”. It is so structured as to keep US government control marginal.

The Fed, which prints the dollar, is self financing. It needs or receives no Congressional funding. The only control over the Fed is the power of the President to make appointments to its 7-member board of governors.

Fed structure

A Fed board member has a 14-year – yes 14 years – tenure, while the US President has merely a 4-year, and a US Congress member just a 2-year, term.

Moreover, if appointed to fill a casual vacancy, a Fed member gets the unexpired term of the vacancy as bonus.

That was how, appointed to a vacancy in Fed Board, but as Chairman directly, Mr Greenspan occupied that position for 28 years. From his seat, he has given farewell to three US Presidents.

Again, no President can alter the Fed’s composition as its members are so appointed that no more than two board members will retire together. Once appointed, Fed Board members – irremovable by the President except “for a cause” – function independently.

The plot thickens now. The Fed functions through 12 Regional Reserve Banks, known as District Banks. Of the 12 Fed Banks, the single most powerful Bank, the backbone of the Fed, is the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

It is the largest in assets; it has monopoly rights to conduct open market operations, that is buying and selling of US Treasury securities and forex, on behalf of the Fed; its chairman is a permanent member of the most powerful Open Market Operations Committee of the Fed. Out of the $3.1 trillion of daily financial and security transactions of the Fed recorded in 2003, it accounted for $2.4 trillion or over 77 per cent. As far back as 1927, it had in its vault 10 per cent of all gold reserves of the world!

But who owns this mighty NY Bank? NY Bank, being unlisted, is not required by US law to declare its shareholding. So who are its shareholders remains a secret.

Different studies on NY Bank have asserted, without being contradicted, that Rothschild Banks of London, Lazard Brothers Bank of Paris, Israel Moses Seiff Banks of Italy, Warburg Banks of Hamburg and Amsterdam, Lehman Brothers Bank of New York, Kuhn Loeb Bank of New York, Chase Manhattan bank of New York, and Goldman Sachs Bank of New York, all of them private financial giants, hold majority shares in NY Bank.

The NY Bank board is elected by its members who have one vote each. This has raised a question, not yet answered for decades now, whether the NY Bank is a public body at all!

That the thousand-odd member banks in NY Bank have only one vote each, regardless of their financial stakes is cited as the only safeguard against private control of NY Bank! But no one has said that the member banks are unconnected to one another.

The origins

This enigma of the US Fed is wrapped in the mystery of its birth. The founder of Forbes’ Magazine, Bertie Charles Forbes, disclosed in 1916, three years after the Federal Reserve Act was passed that representatives of powerful financial interests, namely, JP Morgan, Rockefeller, Warburg, and a Senator, Nelson Aldrich, secretly met in 1910 at Jekyll Island in Georgia, and drafted the bill for instituting the US Federal Reserve System. And two decades later, in the year 1935, in his autobiography, ‘From Farmboy to Financier’, Frank Vanderlip, the Rockefeller representative at Jekyll Island, confessed thus: “I was as secretive, indeed I was as furtive as any conspirator… If it were to be exposed that our particular group had got together and written a banking bill, that bill would have no chance whatever of passage by Congress… I do not feel it is any exaggeration to speak of our secret expedition to Jekyll Island as the occasion of the actual conception of what eventually became the Federal Reserve System.”

Moreover, Warburg was the author of the bill that finally became the Federal Reserve Act.

The secret meet approved the Aldrich Plan which was earlier discredited and dismissed as just a Wall Street Plot particularly because Senator Aldrich, whose daughter was married to John D. Rockefeller, had conceptualised it.

Yet the Fed came into being precisely the way the Jekyll Island group had asked for. President Woodrow himself described the Fed arrangement as “60 to 70 per cent correct” and no more.

Wilson’s law empowered the Fed to print greenback that rules the world, but told the US Treasury to feel satisfied with minting small coins to help Americans to buy coke and coffee! The US Treasury managed to print the dollar only on two occasions, once before the Fed was born and the other after.

In 1862, when bankers demanded interest up to 36 per cent for war loans to government, Abraham Lincoln had to pass a special law to print currency for $450 millions to finance the US civil war. That currency had green colour at the back and so even today the dollar is known as greenback.

A century later, John F Kennedy issued Presidential Order No 11110 (June 4, 1963) to authorise the US Treasury to print some $4.3 billion.

As of now, including this $4.3 billion, some $800 billion have been printed by the US and put into circulation out of which over 99 per cent has been from the Fed.

Estimates show that some two-thirds of the printed dollars of $800 billion is held outside the US. These dollar stocks have now multiplied to become huge forex holdings of $3.8 trillion held by other countries.

Today the stakes of other nations in the dollar and the way the American economy is managed is as much as if not more than the stakes of Americans themselves.

The dollar has become the default global currency essentially for lack of an alternative. More importantly, by its capacity to print and supply more dollars and the power to fix its rate of interest, the Fed influences the global markets. It has, in substance, become a global central bank.

Thus an enigmatic US Fed that had a mysterious birth and even now has unanswered questions on its public character hanging is the de facto central bank of the world.

How is the US Fed the de facto central bank of the world, how does it influence the world economy with the dollar as the global currency and why a global watch over US Fed is needed in the larger interest of all, are captured in the next part.

(The author is a corporate advisor. His e-mail is guru@gurumurthy.net)

(This article was published in the Business Line print edition dated December 28, 2007)
XThese are links to The Hindu Business Line suggested by Outbrain, which may or may not be relevant to the other content on this page. You can read Outbrain's privacy and cookie policy here.

O
P
E
N

close

Recent Article in Today's Paper

Hyderabad Chem to sell 74% stake to Japanese agrochem maker

Hyderabad Chemicals, an agrochemical and pesticides manufacturer, has decided to sell its 74 per cent stake to a Japanese firm Ni... »


Comments to: web.businessline@thehindu.co.in. Copyright © 2014, The Hindu Business Line.