The answer is blowing in the wind
The George brothers’ Avatar small wind turbine is generating electricity for troops in Leh
Ramesh Chand, member, NITI Aayog
Direct benefit transfer (DBT) cannot be a panacea for the agricultural sector’s many problems, given the multiple layers of subsidies from both the Centre and the States, said a top official of NITI Aayog.
As NITI Aayog’s internal committee sets out to explore a method to implement DBT, Ramesh Chand, a thinktank member who chairs the committee, believes that given the complexities involved, the task may not be easy.
“We had a meeting a few days ago. When I started looking at it, I found it quite complex. It’s not as easy as it appears on the surface: you can’t just do DBT (in agriculture) like you did with gas connections and other subsidies,” he told BusinessLine.
One strand of opinion within the government favours direct income support rather than input subsidies. The Economic Survey 2017-18 made a pitch for just such an approach. The Survey prepared, by Chief Economic Advisor Arvind Subramanian and his team, iterated the need for ushering in direct income support in place of farm subsidies for power and fertiliser.
But according to Chand, one of the major complexities is in differentiating between subsidy support and income support. “These are two different things. Subsidy, by definition, means charging less than the price and is always related to use of input, whereas income support is linked to output. So, how will it be worked out is a challenge,” Chand said. He, however, emphasised that there is a need to bring some rationality to subsidies as they are imposing a serious strain on resources.
The basic purpose of subsidy is to promote the use of a particular input, he said, adding that “subsidy is specific whereas income support is very general.”
The Committee, which will submit its report in three months, will also look at whether there is a case for DBT in this sector or whether the subsidy money can be given in the form of income to the farmers on a per-acre basis.
Chand agreed that agriculture was a sensitive issue and that the Committee would have to look at all the options and possibilities before coming out with a mechanism to give the subsidy in the form of DBT or on area basis.
Another question that could come up is: who will get the support? Some States — Andhra Pradesh, for instance — have a large number of absentee landlords. Tenant farmers in Andhra cultivate 60 per cent of the land there; in Bihar, it is about 30 per cent. How can it be ensured that it is these farmers — and not the landlords — who benefit from the income support mechanism?
Asked if a similar method can be adopted as was done with DBT for LPG, Chand said, “You are giving DBT for LPG only to those who are connection holders. In the case of agriculture, if you say we will give DBT on fertiliser, how will you establish whether the farmer is the user of fertiliser? And, therefore, you are reduced to giving this subsidy to all farmers, whose number is not small.”
Besides, in the case of gas, it is easy calculate the subsidy: it can be anchored to the number of cylinders one buys. But what will be the anchor in the case of fertiliser subsidy, asked the NITI Aayog member.
“One way of anchoring it could be to give it to those who are buying fertilisers. But we need to clarify that if we are talking about DBT in inputs, we will be giving DBT to only those who are buying these inputs,” he said.
On the Telangana model of giving ₹4,000 per acre per season to farmers, Chand said, “One is not sure whether what Telangana is doing can actually be called DBT. It is going on a per-acre basis. If you do it on a per-acre basis, you are giving it to someone who doesn’t even intend to use that input. Is there any justification for this? Besides, you also end up giving much less to those who need to use them.”
The Committee, said Chand, has an open mind. “Another challenge is the different subsidies being given. Some subsidy (for example, on fertiliser) is given by the Centre, some by States (for instance, power and canal irrigation) and some by both (in the case of seed). When you are talking of pooling the subsidy, will States be willing to do?,” he wondered.
Another challenge will be to sort out the credit issue, particularly interest subventions. “So a question emerges: will you give subsidy to those farmers who do not have insurance and will you also give to farmers who never borrow? In fact, the credit structure is already like DBT. Then there is issue of drip irrigation: will you be giving it to rain-fed farms? There are many questions to be answered,” said Chand.
The George brothers’ Avatar small wind turbine is generating electricity for troops in Leh
The Spanish flu (1918) devastated a port city like Mumbai. Could the lessons help as we brace for a second ...
Though the number is still woefully small, the good news is that more Indian companies are auditing their ...
Post-pandemic, airlines may have to combine punctuality with heightened passenger services, including safety, ...
Reading continuation chart parttern will tell you
The NSC, PPF and Sukanya Samriddhi are good options
Banks will revert to old NPA reporting format, which may impact their financials
Await cues from global market for further direction
A model rehabilitation project for 100 families of rescued bonded labourers kicks off in Tiruvannamalai, ...
Mallika Srinivasan is the first person from the private sector to head the all-powerful PESB. Will she ring in ...
Murder is a theme that is unlikely to darken and yellow with time, the writer Truman Capote had once said.
Understanding a raga and its philosophical and emotional universe is a daunting task. Author Amit Chaudhuri ...
Marketers are padded up, sponsorship deals have been struck, and campaigns are rolling out. Now let the games ...
And what marketers can possibly do to bring it back in our lives
The agency has changed form over the years but its lustre has not dimmed
Media Factory has purchased the majority stake held by Sam and Lara Balsara of Madison World in Madison Media ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor