Constant rollbacks and erratic decisions will worsen economic situation, says Congress

PTI New Delhi | Updated on September 20, 2019 Published on September 20, 2019

A file photo of Rahul Gandhi, former Congress President

The party accused the government of trying to manage headlines before the ‘Howdy! Modi’ event

The Congress, on Friday, said the government’s “constant rollbacks” may give an “impression of progress through stock market bumps”, but these will lead to worsening of the economic situation and are unlikely to revive investments.

Questioning the timing of the corporate tax cut announcement, the opposition party alleged that it has been dictated by Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ‘Howdy! Modi’ event in the United States. Terming the event as the “world’s most expensive event ever”, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi said he is “amazed” at what Prime Minister Modi is ready to do for a stock market bump ahead of the event in Houston.

“Amazing what PM is ready to do for a stock market bump during his Howdy Indian Economy jamboree. At + 1.4 lakh crore Rs. The Houston event is the world’s most expensive event, ever! But, no event can hide the reality of the economic mess ‘Howdy! Modi’ has driven India into (sic),” Gandhi said on Twitter.

The Congress party said in its official Twitter handle, “The constant rollbacks and erratic decisions taken by this government may give the impression of progress through stock market bumps but will further decrease investor confidence and lead to worsening of the economic situation in the country.”

The government slashed the corporate tax rates for companies by almost 10 percentage points to 25.17 per cent and offered a lower rate to 17.01 per cent for new manufacturing firms to boost economic growth rate from a six-year low by incentivising investments to help create jobs.

Will it revive investment?

Congress leader Jairam Ramesh welcomed the reduction in corporate tax rates but expressed doubts on whether the step will revive investment. Asking whether it was the Prime Minister’s “trump card”, he said the government’s move does nothing to dispel the fear that pervades India Inc.

Also read: Corporate tax rate cut: Here’s what it means for India Inc

“A headline-itis afflicted, panic-stricken Modi sarkar has cut corporate tax rates less than 3 months after a Budget, and 4 months before the next one. This is welcome but it is doubtful whether investment will revive. This does nothing to dispel fear that pervades in India Inc,” Ramesh said on Twitter, adding, “Timing of FM announcement dictated by #HowdyModi event. PM can now say, ‘I have come to Texas promising lower Taxes’ Is this his ‘trump card’?”

Another Congress leader, Abhishek Singhvi, said drastic reduction in corporate tax rate is good, but the arbitrage between highest effective individual tax rate of 42 per cent and higher effective corporate rate of 25 per cent begins to look absurd.

“Good: GOI, FM reduce corporate tax rate drastically. But arbitrage between highest individual tax rate (42 per cent effective) and highest effective corporate rate of 25 per cent begins to look even more absurd. If animal instincts are required for growth, I predict 35 per cent Individual rate yields more than 42 per cent (sic)!” he tweeted.

Announcing the latest set of measures to jump-start flagging growth, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said the reduction in tax rates has been done by promulgating an ordinance to an amendment to the Income Tax Act.

Another stimulus package

Battling a six-year low economic growth and a 45-year high unemployment rate, Sitharaman announced the step two-and-half-months after presenting her maiden Budget, that was hailed as “development-friendly” and “future-oriented”. The fiscal measure announced by her will cost the government Rs 1.45 lakh crore in revenue annually.

Also Read: Government slashes taxes for corporate, new manufacturing firms

In the fourth phase of post-budget economic stimulus measures, Sitharaman cut base corporate tax for existing companies to 22 per cent from current 30 per cent and for new manufacturing firms, incorporated after October 1, 2019 and starting operations before March 31, 2023, to 15 per cent from current 25 per cent.

Published on September 20, 2019
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor