Mobility paves Samsung’s silver path
The Korean giant’s early bet on mobile phones helped it hit the $10-bn mark in India, but in its 25th year it ...
Only the owner of the goods or person entitled to the goods is liable to pay storage or demurrage charges to the port trusts and not the ships or its agents known as steamer agents, the Supreme Court has ruled in a judgment that settles a long-standing conflict within the shipping industry over the matter.
The statutory scheme of the Major Port Trusts Act 1963 is crystal clear, a three-member larger Bench of the top court led by Justice RF Nariman wrote in a August 5, 2020, order.
“Until the stage of landing (of goods) and removal to a place of storage, the steamer’s agent or the vessel itself may be made liable for rates payable by the vessel for services performed to the vessel,” the top court said.
“Post landing and removal to a place of storage, detention charges for goods that are stored, and demurrage payable thereon from this point on, i.e., when the Port Trust takes charge of the goods from the vessel, or from any other person who can be said to be owner as defined under Section 2(o), it is only the owner of the goods or other persons entitled to the goods (who may be beneficially entitled as well) that the Port Trust has to look to for payment of storage or demurrage charges,” the Bench that also included Justice Navin Sinha and Justice Indira Banerjee, concluded.
The apex court order came on an appeal filed by Cochin Port Trust against a September 27, 2011, order of the Kerala High Court involving Arebee Star Maritime Agencies (P) Ltd.
The court was asked to decide on whom the Port Trust has to fasten the liability for payment of storage/demurrage charges — the consignee or the steamer agent.
“The correct position in law is that after the Port Trust takes charge of the goods, and issues a receipt therefor, and thereafter stores the goods in a place belonging to it, such storage charge cannot be to the account of the vessel or an agent of the vessel,” the court ruled.
The bill of lading being endorsed by the steamer agent is different from the bill of lading being endorsed by the owner of the goods, it observed.
“In the first case, the endorsement leads to delivery; in the second case, the endorsement leads to passing of title (over the goods). For the reasons mentioned in the judgment, both stages are irrelevant in determining who is to pay storage charges — we have held that up to the point that the Port Trust takes charge of the goods, and gives receipt therefor, the steamer agent may be held liable for Port Trust dues in connection with services rendered qua unloading of goods, but that thereafter, the importer, owner, consignee or their agent is liable to pay demurrage charges for storage of goods,” the court said.
Based on this, the top court disposed of the appeal filed against the Kerala High Court order.
Shipping industry sources said that vessels and steamer agents can now be “confident and certain” that once goods are landed at a port and pass into the port’s custody in exchange for a receipt, the vessel and its agents are absolved from all liabilities towards the cargo, including for payment of storage and demurrage charges levied by the port trusts.
“Irrespective of whether delivery orders are issued or not, any charges accrued on the cargo once custody of the cargo has passed to the Port Trust, will be to the account of the cargo owner and not to the vessel and her agents,” said a steamer agent.
The Korean giant’s early bet on mobile phones helped it hit the $10-bn mark in India, but in its 25th year it ...
Antrix should adopt a different tactic than merely fighting over jurisdiction: Experts
Invest in relationships, enterprise, behaviour, effort and learning
From different types of osmoses to new membranes, researchers have come up with ways of drawing water
High valuation and stiff competition from larger players are a dampener
Investors with a short-term perspective can buy The New India Assurance Company (NIACL) stock at current ...
₹1490 • HDFC Bank S1S2R1R2COMMENT 1475146015051520 Fresh short positions are recommended with a stiff ...
Will a stock continue its current trend or will it reverse? We tell you how you can read chart patterns to ...
What makes the new crop of young Indian cricketers such game-changing winners? Over and above their talent, ...
In these isolated times when people yearn for a slice of the familiar, amateur and professional chefs are ...
‘You ready to go to work?’ Joe Biden had asked Kamala Harris before naming her as his running mate. ‘Oh my ...
Writer Narendra’s latest book, rich with vignettes from Bastar and his native village in Uttar Pradesh, ...
Digital is becoming dominant media, but are companies and their ad agencies transforming fast enough to make a ...
Slow Network, promoted by journalist-lyricist Neelesh Misra, pushes rural products and experiences
How marketers can use the traditional exchange of festive wishes meaningfully
For Fortune, a brand celebrating its 20th anniversary, it was a rude shock to become the butt of social media ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor