Uproar in Parliament over ‘cash-for-votes’ scam

The 2008 ‘cash-for-votes’ scam today returned to haunt the UPA Government with a united Opposition in Parliament demanding the resignation of the Prime Minister, Dr Manmohan Singh, in view of fresh charges that bribe was paid during the trust vote but the Government was dismissive.

Citing correspondence between the US Embassy and its Government revealed by the Wikileaks, the Opposition parties created uproar in both Houses of Parliament, saying the appearance of the media reports had “shamed” the country and it showed the “murder of democracy’’.

Responding to the attack, the Finance Minister, Mr Pranab Mukherjee, was dismissive, saying the charges pertained to the 14th Lok Sabha and could not be discussed in the current one.

He asserted in the Rajya Sabha that the cables cited by the Wikileaks website were correspondence between a sovereign government and its mission abroad and that he could not confirm or deny the allegations.

“Each Lok Sabha is sovereign in its time. What happened in the 14th Lok Sabha cannot be decided in the 15th Lok Sabha...Government of the day is accountable to the 15th Lok Sabha and not to the 14th Lok Sabha. Whatever happened in the 14th Lok Sabha has come to an end” with the end of the tenure, he said.

He also asked whether Mr Jaitley was satisfied that “whatever has appeared in newspaper report is admissible in the court of law’’.

The communication between the US Embassy and its Government enjoys diplomatic immunity and “it is not possible for the Government to either confirm it or deny it,” Mr Pranab Mukherjee said amid din.

Seeking clarification on his statement, Mr Jaitley said: “If what has appeared (in the newspaper) is correct, it is a commission of offence in India.”

He said the diplomatic immunity may be available to the US diplomats but the same cannot be claimed for offences like “bribery” committed by Indians in the country.

Mr Jaitley also disagreed with Mr Pranab Mukherjee’s contention on the issue of accountability of then government (UPA-1) to the present Lok Sabha. “All these factors do not apply when the offence was committed outside the House,” he said.

“You are guilty of cover,” the BJP leader alleged, prompting a sharp reaction from Mr Pranab Mukherjee, who retorted, “If you have the courage, go to court.”

Soon after, the House was adjourned till 2 p.m. in view of the uproar.

Earlier, Mr Jaitley raised the issue when the House met, saying “It is conclusively clear that this government survived on political and moral sin.”

Amid shouts of ‘shame, shame’ from BJP Benches, he said: “A government which survived on such a political sin has no authority to even continue for one minute. We demand this government must resign immediately.”

Frequently interrupted by Congress members, Mr Jaitley said the expose reflected the “extraordinary depressing situation how our democracy has been reduced.... The leak completely establishes the worst that we had feared at that time (2008).”

Leaders of all major parties including the CPI-M, CPI, JD(U) and BJD joined Mr Jaitley in demanding the resignation of the government forthwith. They also demanded the Prime Minister to come and explain.

In the din, the House was adjourned till noon.

In the Lok Sabha, the CPI leader, Mr Gurudas Dasgupta, raised the issue as soon as the House met.

“Never in the history of Indian democracy has such a news appeared in newspapers... money was paid to members....this is a murder of democracy,” Mr Dasgupta said.

“If the Prime Minister does not deny this, he should resign immediately,” he said.

The CPI leader wondered “whether the control room of the government is in Delhi or in Washington?”

Leader of the Opposition Ms Sushma Swaraj said the expose has shamed Indian democracy.

Certain matters that took place right under the nose of a “so-called honest Prime Minister have come to light”, she said.

She recalled that three BJP members had brought cash to the House during the debate on trust vote in 2008 but the then Speaker had ordered an inquiry against them instead of taking cognisance of the matter.

“An official of the American Embassy was shown a chest full of cash. Is this a display of the bullying tactics of the government or its shamelessness,” Ms Swaraj said, evoking protests from Congress members.

“This government has lost the moral authority to continue in office and the Prime Minister should resign immediately,” she said.

The Samajwadi Party leader, Mr Mulayam Singh Yadav, asked the Speaker, Ms Meira Kumar, to allow a discussion on the matter saying his party had also played a key role in saving the UPA-I Government.

“We had also worked to save the government in 2008. If all are painted by the same brush, we also stand to be maligned. Only a discussion on this matter can clear our name,” Mr Yadav said.

At this point, members from both the Opposition and ruling Benches were on their feet raising slogans and prompting the Speaker to adjourn the proceedings till noon.

When the House re-assembled, similar scenes were witnessed.

The Left and the BJP were seen having a sort of floor coordination on the issue, with Mr Dasgupta twice walking over to the BJP benches to tell its leadership not to allow their members to storm the Well but protest from their seats.

The RLD leader, Mr Ajit Singh, who has been adversely commented in the Wikileaks report, was not seen in the House nor any of his party MPs.

The JD(S) chief, Mr Sharad Yadav, termed the Wikileaks expose as “very serious” and said though we need to have good relations with the US, “19 of our (opposition) MPs were bought over and it seems the transaction was done with the involvement of US Embassy officials. .... It is just not possible that 19 MPs crossed the floor without any allurement.”

“The US Embassy in India is running the country. This is not good. The Wikileaks has exposed everything. It shows that every word reaches this Embassy. Its officials are also shown the cash to be distributed”, said Mr Yadav, amid continuous interruptions by Congress members.

“The US is not our Lord Mountbatten. It looks as if they are telling us what to do,” he said amid shouts of ‘shame, shame’ from the Opposition benches.

Alleging that there could be no bigger attack on democracy than this, Mr Yadav demanded that the Prime Minister should come to the House and explain. He also wanted a high-level inquiry into the expose made by the Wikileaks.

The Wikileaks report has vindicated the Opposition which has all along been alleging that the MPs have been bought by the Government to win the confidence vote and it could go ahead with the Indo-US nuclear deal, he said.

Mr Ramchandra Dome (CPI-M) said the cash-for-vote scam was the “most shameful chapter of Indian democracy” and the “shameful revelations” have proved the Opposition right.

He said whatever happened was a criminal offence and therefore, a criminal investigation should be instituted immediately.

The Prime Minister, Mr Dome said, should “own moral responsibility for all this’’.

As Mr Dome spoke, the Opposition members stood up and raised slogans ‘PM isteefa do’ (Prime Minister resign).

When the Deputy Speaker, Mr Karia Munda, who was in the Chair, asked the Congress member, Mr Sanjay Nirupam, to speak, almost the entire Opposition stood up and protested vociferously.

This forced adjournment of the House till 2 p.m.

COMMENT NOW