Money & Banking

Why India’s big plan to bring rupee trading home is an uphill task

Bloomberg | Updated on November 26, 2019 Published on November 26, 2019

As London does more rupee trading than Mumbai, authorities in India are taking steps to get foreigners to transact onshore. Analysts say that will be no easy task.

“There is no good reason for market participants to switch from excellent global trading hubs such as Singapore and London,” said Jeffrey Halley, a senior market analyst at Oanda Asia Pacific, who has extensively traded currencies in offshore markets over a three-decade career. For Schroder Investment Management, the need to add more counterparties would just increase investors’ trading costs.

Authorities in India are concerned a surge in rupee trading overseas threatens the stability of the currency, especially in times of stress. That worry has intensified after London overtook Mumbai as the top trading centre. In response, India has been moving to make its onshore market more attractive and preparing to replicate offshore centres in specially-designated financial zones within the country.

A 3-star menu

For Halley, that is like fighting the waves. Institutions have access to a Michelin 3-star menu of currencies from all over the world, all in one centre, in hubs such as Singapore and London, he said. Banks would have no incentive, from a purely cost basis alone, to set up a separate operation onshore.

At issue is the rise of derivatives known as non-deliverable forwards (NDFs) bets on the direction of a currency made in offshore centres, beyond the rules of domestic authorities and without the need to deliver the currency itself. The contracts, which allow investors to hedge, arbitrage and speculate in non-convertible currencies such as the rupee, can be traced back to the 1990s but have surged in popularity in recent years.

London has become the biggest centre for trading the rupee, according to the latest survey by the Bank for International Settlements in September. Average daily volumes for the currency in the UK soared to $46.8 billion in April, exceeding the $34.5 billion recorded in India. Volumes have also substantially jumped in other centres like Singapore, New York and Dubai.

NDF market

It will be a better world for us if there is no NDF market, but we cannot wish it away, former Reserve Bank of India chief Duvvuri Subbarao said during the US taper tantrum of 2013 when the rupee was plummeting to record lows on an almost daily basis, with NDFs blamed for a surge in speculative trading. In a report in July, an RBI task force on offshore rupee markets recommended getting trading back to the onshore market by extending trading hours and allowing local banks to offer price quotes to foreigners round the clock. It also said non-deliverable forwards trading should be permitted in special centres within India that would replicate the attractiveness of offshore locations.

In October, the RBI said it would allow rupee trading by customers outside the jurisdiction of the domestic economy in low-tax venues.

The International Financial Services Centre (IFSC) in the Gujarat International Finance Tec-City, or GIFT City, an effort by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to replicate the market in Singapore, is awaiting regulatory approvals before becoming the country’s first venue to offer NDF rupee contracts.

In the existing onshore over-the-counter market, foreigners are allowed to hedge only on the basis of their underlying exposure. They can only enter into plain vanilla forwards and option contracts and are generally not allowed to rebook a contract once cancelled.

BSE’s subsidiary, India International Exchange, which will probably spearhead the launch of rupee derivatives, says the new venue will be cost-competitive. But that alone won’t be enough to attract trading, according to investors.

Manu George, senior investment director at Schroder Investment Management in Singapore, said it is difficult to see a situation where offshore trading migrates to within India’s borders. “India is not a major forex trading hub and so it’s inefficient from a firm’s point of view as there are more counterparties to generally trade FX than onshore in India,” he said. Adding further counterparties adds to the cost and expense of set-up and trading. India’s notorious flip-flops on rules remain a concern, according to Renuka Ramnath, founder and chief executive officer of Multiples Alternate Asset Management Pvt Ltd, a private equity company with close to $1 billion of assets under management.

Investors have been a bit disappointed with frequently changing regulations, which keep them perpetually nervous about whether the assumptions they made before coming to India are indeed going to hold, she said at an event at the GIFT City in August discussing ways to bring rupee trading onshore.

To be sure, India has made some progress in addressing those concerns. The government is establishing a unified regulator for IFSCs, which will eliminate the need for dealing with each regulator separately. And to boost existing onshore trading, the Securities and Exchange Board of India has tried to ease some know-your-customer requirements. Still, much more must be done, according to Sanjay Guglani, CEO at Silverdale Capital Pte Ltd, a Singapore-based fund manager that manages about $1 billion of assets.

Bloomberg

Published on November 26, 2019
  1. Comments will be moderated by The Hindu Business Line editorial team.
  2. Comments that are abusive, personal, incendiary or irrelevant cannot be published.
  3. Please write complete sentences. Do not type comments in all capital letters, or in all lower case letters, or using abbreviated text. (example: u cannot substitute for you, d is not 'the', n is not 'and').
  4. We may remove hyperlinks within comments.
  5. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name, to avoid rejection.