Row over Tipu anniversary celebrations

BL16_DC1_THINK2
After over two centuries, Mysore’s famed ruler Tipu Sultan is back in the limelight — for all the wrong reasons. His resurrection, by those who support him as well as those who oppose him, is a classic example of the use and abuse of history.
Tipu, who ruled Mysore between 1780 and 1799, lived in an age when power politics played a bigger role than religion in shaping policies.
On the one hand, he had given liberal donations to many temples including the one at Srirangam. On the other, he has been accused of destroying temples and killing hundreds of Melkote Iyengars. How do we understand this dual personality? Was he a liberal or a religious fanatic?
The answer is, he was neither. Like many rulers of his times, he was an imperialist who tried to perpetuate his own power and authority. The accusation that he killed Hindus in Malabar on religious grounds does not stand scrutiny as he also killed Muslims in his fights against the Hyderabad Nizams. So, it is inappropriate to give religious colour to his actions.
What’s the context?As observed by historian Bipan Chandra, communalism is a modern ideology that cannot be pre-dated to the second half of the 19th century. It is historically incorrect to apply communal motives to pre-colonial times.
The first communal riots in India, as noted by British crime records and acknowledged by eminent social historian Sumit Sarkar in his work, Modern India, occurred in the 1880s in Calcutta when two communities clashed over cow protection as advocated by the Arya Samaj which has also done pioneering work in fighting for a casteless society through the promotion of inter-caste marriages. The context for the clashes was extremely limited — the spread of modern education and the divide and rule policies of the British after the 1857 revolt that created an ideological gulf between Hindus and Muslims.
But today, with 78 per cent literacy, we are again fighting on issues such as beef consumption, forgetting the multi cultural fabric of our society.
Simply irresponsibleThe blame should go to politicians and intellectuals for making irresponsible statements. For instance, the comparison between Tipu and Sivaji by writer and artist Girish Karnad should not have come at a time when the country is caught up in a debate on intolerance and beef. The two historic personalities belong to different times and spaces in history and had their own strengths as leaders.
While Sivaji was a visionary who always tried to ensure caste balance in his administration, Tipu was an infant democrat who planted the Jacobin Tree of Liberty in his palace influenced by the ideals of the French Revolution.
Actually, he was the only leader who could grasp the game plan of the British for the piecemeal conquest of India. He rightly identified loopholes in warfare and trained his troops on European lines. Using the names of these two leaders for political ends is an abuse of their history.
The medieval Bhakti saint, Kabir, was the first intellectual to plead for Hindu-Muslim unity, something we are unable to realise even today.
Secularism is no longer a social necessity or political game plan for the country — it is an economic imperative as any deviation from this could hit investments and the business climate.
Indian researchers are working on cells that can store more energy, last longer
To fix a broken bone, doctors often harvest another bone from the patient’s body or from someone else. It ...
Superconductors from IIScScientists at IISc Bangalore have invented a device with a nanocrystal structure ...
Engineering and construction giant L&T has won a licence from the Council of Scientific & Industrial ...
Will a stock continue its current trend or will it reverse? We tell you how you can read chart patterns to ...
Sensex and Nifty 50 saw selling interest on Friday and slumped; selling pressure could continue
Investors with a long-term horizon can consider this offer
Most AMCs have been sending out cryptic e-mails. We tell you how to read between the lines
In these isolated times when people yearn for a slice of the familiar, amateur and professional chefs are ...
With strokes of quirky humour, Partha Pratim Deb uses pulp, terracotta, glass and discarded cloth to create ...
Given the events in Washington DC on January 6, this week’s quiz is all about buildings that house or housed ...
While good writing wars against the cliché, television gives it a natural home
Digital is becoming dominant media, but are companies and their ad agencies transforming fast enough to make a ...
Slow Network, promoted by journalist-lyricist Neelesh Misra, pushes rural products and experiences
How marketers can use the traditional exchange of festive wishes meaningfully
For Fortune, a brand celebrating its 20th anniversary, it was a rude shock to become the butt of social media ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor