The answer is blowing in the wind
The George brothers’ Avatar small wind turbine is generating electricity for troops in Leh
To prevent family-owned listed companies from short-changing minority shareholders, our regulators seem to be placing increasing faith in independent directors (IDs). SEBI made sweeping changes to its listing regulations in 2018 to enlarge the role, responsibilities and eligibility criteria for IDs. In 2019, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs prescribed compulsory registration and written exam requirements for IDs. SEBI’s new discussion paper last week appears to be a fresh attempt to reinforce the independence of IDs with more stringent rules for appointment and removal. Presently, IDs are recommended for appointment by the Nomination and Remuneration Committee (NRC) of the Board to be later ratified through an ordinary resolution. SEBI suggests replacing this with a dual approval process, where the NRC’s recommendation will need to be approved by a majority of a company’s minority shareholders in addition to being put through an ordinary resolution. Removal of IDs will need to go through the same process. To align ID interests with shareholders, it suggests the grant of long-vesting Employee Stock Options (ESOPs).
While these proposals are driven by good intent, some of them may be tripped by practical difficulties. Giving minority shareholders veto powers is aimed at thwarting promoters from anointing yes-men as IDs. But the problem is that retail shareholders are mostly apathetic to corporate voting exercises, while institutions are loath to vote against incumbent managements. For well-run companies backed by promoters without ill-intent, the suggested process for ID appointment will only raise the compliance burden. While it is important that minority shareholders do have a voice on corporate Boards, having too many non-executive directors can hamstring promoters with substantial skin-in-the-game. It is also unfair to expect IDs who occupy multiple Board seats across sectors to weigh in on everything from a company’s related party deals to mergers and takeovers. In fact, to encourage diligent candidates to apply to be IDs, regulators may need to consider narrowing the scope of ID responsibilities. Their statutory obligations must perhaps be restricted to checking governance infractions; participation in strategic decisions should be left to the ID’s discretion depending on sector expertise and qualifications.
To attract qualified executives to apply to be IDs, the compensation for the role does need to match its wide-ranging responsibilities. But whether ESOPs are the best way to go about this is moot, as they have been known to create perverse incentives for corporate executives to focus on the short term and even window-dress numbers to please markets. Instead, regulators can consider prescribing a slab-wise fee structure for IDs based on company size and complexity. They also need to devise ways to expand the limited pool of managers who are today willing to apply for ID positions.
The George brothers’ Avatar small wind turbine is generating electricity for troops in Leh
The Spanish flu (1918) devastated a port city like Mumbai. Could the lessons help as we brace for a second ...
Though the number is still woefully small, the good news is that more Indian companies are auditing their ...
Post-pandemic, airlines may have to combine punctuality with heightened passenger services, including safety, ...
Three-in-one: Passive debt funds come at a low cost and have high-quality portfolios. Some offer return ...
Trend in the rupee movement and Q4 earnings can give direction to the market
There is room for improvement in fund transfer options
Silver looks positive but lacks the higher volumes required to substantiate bullishness
Murder is a theme that is unlikely to darken and yellow with time, the writer Truman Capote had once said.
The iconic punk rock band took a whole generation along as they toured the globe for 22 years
On April 10, 1970, Paul McCartney announced that he was leaving The Beatles for ‘personal and professional ...
A model rehabilitation project for 100 families of rescued bonded labourers kicks off in Tiruvannamalai, ...
Marketers are padded up, sponsorship deals have been struck, and campaigns are rolling out. Now let the games ...
And what marketers can possibly do to bring it back in our lives
The agency has changed form over the years but its lustre has not dimmed
Media Factory has purchased the majority stake held by Sam and Lara Balsara of Madison World in Madison Media ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor