Bonjour, new guests from small-town India
Puneet Dhawan of Accor is brimming with ideas on ways to revive the hospitality sector
The Wanchoo Committee of yore, which found tax amnesty schemes morally reprehensible what with the same set of defaulters making use of them repeatedly and blithely unmindful of the admonition, strangely recommended the setting up of a Settlement Commission to which a tax defaulter could unburden his woes and get partial relief from tax and a complete reprieve from penalty and jail term.
That Settlement Commission mechanism was nothing but a permanent if quasi-amnesty scheme. Settlement smacks of the concept of plea bargaining that is alien to Indian criminal jurisprudence.
So much so that in 1979, in Commissioner of Income Tax vs BN Bhattacharjee & Anr, Justice VR Krishna Iyer of the Supreme Court made no secret of his displeasure with the mechanism and castigated it as serving the interests of tycoons and indulging in their tax offences.
Indeed, the Settlement Commission used to beckon those who were caught in an adversarial proceeding like income tax raid. The government closed this loophole with a salutary amendment that one cannot knock at the doors of the Commission once an income- tax search or raid has been carried out. To prevent people from knocking at the doors of the Commission repeatedly, the UPA II government rightly made the mechanism available only once in the lifetime of an assessee.
The Commission proceedings are held behind closed doors and not reported so that no one gets a wind of how the compromise was reached between the Revenue Department and the tax defaulter, brokered and midwifed by the Commission. It is an anachronism in a milieu of transparency and openness. And, it is certainly at odds with faceless assessment and appeals. There is no reason why a defaulter should be indulged even once when the honest pay their taxes during their entire careers, be in employment or in business or profession. So, by saying that no one can file a fresh application after February1, 2021 and that all pending cases will be heard by an interim board, the Finance Bill 2021 has gone as far as it possibly could in giving the Settlement Commission provisions a burial.
A good riddance indeed that was perceived more as an insult to the honest taxpayer than as a shoulder to cry on for defaulters. There is no reason why defaulters should be indulged if they offer to pay up an additional income tax of ₹10 lakh — the entry level threshold to be eligible for knocking at the doors of the Commission — or more to the exchequer.
There can be compounding schemes for minor and administrative lapses like failure to file income tax return on time or company annual return on time, etc., but to allow defaulters to compromise or avail themselves of amnesty schemes under the pretence of remorse amounts to the state kowtowing to them.
The income-tax administration should improve tax compliance through better investigation and surveillance. Instead of foisting on tax deductors the responsibility of fostering the tax return filing habit, the tax sleuths must fan out to areas of opulence and accost them.
There should be greater scrutiny on people owning swanky cars and living in palatial bungalows. Wealth tax should be used in conjunction with income tax not only to garner more revenue but also to juxtapose one’s income in the context of one’s wealth. The Modi government has done well to send the signal that it is not going to indulge defaulters even once.
The writer is a Chennai-based Chartered Accountant
Puneet Dhawan of Accor is brimming with ideas on ways to revive the hospitality sector
Citroen’s first vehicle sports a novel design and European interiors. It is also meant to be as comfortable as ...
The pandemic is only the tip of the iceberg that the country’s cash-poor airlines — both regional and national ...
The government is yet to specify the framework of its recently announced old vehicle scrappage policy
Here is a checklist that equips you to discern the market nuances
Sensex, Nifty 50 have witnessed sharp decline
The fund has consistently outperformed S&P BSE 100 TRI over one, three and five years
Returns are superior to immediate annuity plans, but SCSS can secure better rates for new investors sooner if ...
With the public looking beyond mainstream media for reports from the ground, independent digital platforms are ...
A book on Badri Narayan is a tribute — albeit a belated one — to an artist who did not enjoy the recognition ...
The country hasn’t had a quiet moment since the military seized power on February 1
The Tatmadaw sees itself as an embodiment of the nationalist soul of Myanmar. But their brand of nationalism ...
Its name is the starting point of a brand’s journey and can make a big difference in the success sweepstakes
Sober spirits are the in thing
A peek into where ad spends went last year and where they are headed tomorrow
Can Swiggy Instamart disrupt the ecommerce groceries space, currently ruled by the Amazons and Big Baskets? ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...