There are few winners from India's crackdown on cottonseed pricing. The Government's move to cap the royalties an affiliate of US-based Monsanto can charge to license its technology for genetically modified (GM) seeds is short-sighted. It rekindles old fears about India's cavalier attitude to intellectual property and could leave Prime Minister Narendra Modi facing some awkward questions as he meets President Barack Obama in Washington this week.
GM cotton has been commercially available in India since 2002 and has helped to transform the country from a net importer into the world's largest producer of the raw material used to make fabrics. Nine-tenths of India's total cotton acreage is planted with seeds made with Monsanto technology. Globally, the commodity accounts for 3.5 per cent of the U.S.-listed company's revenues.
Monsanto, through its local joint venture, licenses its technology to local producers that make seeds and sell them to farmers. It receives a royalty fee for each packet sold. A 450-gram packet of so-called “Bt cotton” seeds sells for up to Rs 1,000 ($15) and delivers a Rs 163 royalty. Under the new rules, effective April, India will cap the price per packet at Rs 800 and the royalty at Rs 49.
The move will override bilateral contracts that Monsanto has negotiated with its local partners and is unlikely to encourage more competition in an industry where barriers to entry are high. The measures also appear to benefit local seed makers more than indebted and despondent cotton farmers.
India insists Monsanto, which also sells maize and corn seeds in the country through a separate locally listed subsidiary, is welcome to leave if it does not want to abide by the new rules. Yet it is hard to believe that India could produce home-grown technology that is equally effective. That has led to worries that authorities may simply cancel Monsanto's patent in the same way that India has often dealt with international pharmaceutical companies.
Politicians are under pressure to act after two consecutive droughts, but it is a dangerous game. Genetically modified seeds tend to lose their resistance to insects over a number of years. Companies have to keep investing to develop new variants. Monsanto's latest cotton technology has just been launched in Australia but is not yet available in India. Overly stringent measures could lead to a reversal of India's good cotton fortune.
(The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are her own.)
Quick facts India announced on March 9 that it would fix the price of cotton seeds in the country. The new regulated prices are applicable for the financial year that runs from April 2016 to March 2017. “Bt cotton” seeds have been genetically modified to have insect-resistant traits. Mahyco Monsanto Biotech India is a privately held 50-50 joint venture between Maharashtra Hybrid Seeds and Monsanto Holdings. It sub-licenses the cotton seed technology to around 50 Indian seed companies. Shares in Monsanto India, a separate publicly listed local subsidiary which specialises in corn and vegetable seeds, have fallen 25% so far this year, against a 3% decline in the benchmark S&P BSE Sensex Index. |