Packing batteries with more punch
Indian researchers are working on cells that can store more energy, last longer
Us and them: Members of a Nair caste organisation march in Palakkad, Kerala, last year to protest against the entry of women of menstruating age at the Sabarimala shrine. - K K Mustafah - The Hindu
In the last months of 2018 we saw sections of women conduct aggressive street protests in Kerala, claiming to defend a temple aachaaram — ritualised practice that is said to be anchored in ‘tradition’.
This was ostensibly worked to protect a celibate god, Ayyappa, from women of menstruating age. Savarna women of an older generation who had broken moulds to secure citizenship and a voice for themselves — for instance, writer and educationist M Leelavathi — were aghast at the response of these younger women. Perhaps that was not surprising, for Leelavathi probably remembered vividly the immense barrier of aachaaram that her generation had to defy in order to gain visibility and voice. In contrast, the women on the streets claiming to be “mere devotees” and not the least political, were used to aacharam that had, by now, been shrunk to fit their homes. They spoke for purity and brahminical authority and equated it with the “defence of Hinduism”. These protesters were often highly educated professionals with independent incomes and lives.
Sometimes an anthropological distance is the only way one can survive the vertigo that the naked display of public aggression provokes. I told myself: Yet another paradox in this land of development paradoxes. For, the celebrated Kerala Model of the 1970s rested on a paradox — that of high social development despite poor economic development. Then came the gender paradox of Kerala — of the persistence of very high levels of patriarchal oppression despite high levels of education, lower birth rate and better health status among women. Here was a third savarna paradox — women with high access to social and political citizenship agitating against their own civil rights, claiming that temples are not public places. Most of them would agree that the state needed to intervene everywhere to secure gender equality — at home, at work, in public places — except in temples.
The key to understanding this, I think, is in the history of aachaaram in 20th-century Kerala and its role as the core around which a new upper-caste Hindu imagination condensed during that time. By the early 20th century, pre-modern ritualised routine practices that defined upper-caste lives were challenged by the standards of modern knowledge and the democratisation of society. Such practices of the upper-caste elites were subjected to scrutiny and revision according to Victorian-neo-brahminical standards, and confined to temples and savarna homes. Indeed, it was this that came to be marked as community reform among the Nairs and the brahmins. The contrast between what came to be perceived as the “true core” of upper-caste Hindu culture and the anti-brahminical ritual practices devised by Sreenarayana Guru in his effort to reimagine a Hindu community beyond caste is stark.
The new reformed savarna streedharmam included the responsibility to preserve faith in God and piety at home. Women’s domestic responsibilities thus included managing temple worship and offerings at regular times of the year, daily rituals, and observing the menstrual taboo. Investigating the ambivalent freedom of educated women in Kerala, sociologist Shoba Arun remarks, drawing from the ideas of French sociologist and philosopher Pierre Bourdieu, that their lives here are a tightrope walk that balances “female capital” and “feminine capital”. The former refers to the capabilities and benefits from citizenship secured through public action and social development. The latter is about beliefs, practice and skill in performance of rituals, which women must acquire in order to be ‘good’. The adherence to or performance of aachaaram is also the key manner in which they express their symbolic difference from — and superiority to — other castes.
It is no surprise that the Nair Service Society, the caste organisation of the Nairs (who form a prominent part of the neo-savarna community), gained the most out of the upsurge of aachaaravaadi women. It was indeed like the anti-communist ‘Liberation Struggle’ of June 1959 — exactly 60 years ago — in which Syrian Christian women flooded the streets claiming that “Christianity was in danger” and the gains went not to all Christians but the elite among them. And like the anti-Mandal women, whose lament about the ‘nation’ suffering from falling professional standards because of reservations, who secured gains for the upper-caste men. What we saw then was the defenders of caste privilege using the “Hindus in danger” as a dog whistle to keep the Savarkarites in the RSS at bay and keep the Kerala savarna going. I don’t know whether I should lament or rejoice.
J Devika is a historian and critic based in Thiruvananthapuram
Indian researchers are working on cells that can store more energy, last longer
To fix a broken bone, doctors often harvest another bone from the patient’s body or from someone else. It ...
Superconductors from IIScScientists at IISc Bangalore have invented a device with a nanocrystal structure ...
Engineering and construction giant L&T has won a licence from the Council of Scientific & Industrial ...
Will a stock continue its current trend or will it reverse? We tell you how you can read chart patterns to ...
Sensex and Nifty 50 saw selling interest on Friday and slumped; selling pressure could continue
Investors with a long-term horizon can consider this offer
Most AMCs have been sending out cryptic e-mails. We tell you how to read between the lines
In these isolated times when people yearn for a slice of the familiar, amateur and professional chefs are ...
With strokes of quirky humour, Partha Pratim Deb uses pulp, terracotta, glass and discarded cloth to create ...
Given the events in Washington DC on January 6, this week’s quiz is all about buildings that house or housed ...
While good writing wars against the cliché, television gives it a natural home
Digital is becoming dominant media, but are companies and their ad agencies transforming fast enough to make a ...
Slow Network, promoted by journalist-lyricist Neelesh Misra, pushes rural products and experiences
How marketers can use the traditional exchange of festive wishes meaningfully
For Fortune, a brand celebrating its 20th anniversary, it was a rude shock to become the butt of social media ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor