Travel pass: Pros may outweigh cons
IATA’s mobile application will allow travellers to store and manage certifications for Covid-19 tests or ...
BL09_THINK2_DC
The benami transactions amendment Bill 2016 cleared by the Cabinet recently commits the same mistake as the original 1988 Act. While the Modi government must be complimented for instituting authority for confiscating benami properties when the earlier governments prevaricated, it too has missed the elephant in the room.
The phenomenon of benami cannot be examined in isolation. It is an offshoot of the phenomenon of black money.
When the income tax law sets store by the Annual Information Report (AIR) under which bank managers, managers of mutual funds, registrar of properties, are mandated to tip off the taxman wherever transactions of specified threshold are done, it is baffling that the benami law expects the authorities constituted under it to zero in on benami transactions on their own steam.
Learn from past
More than two decades ago, the Delhi High Court found that the promoter of Sofia Investments had tried a familiar trick — launder his black money on the eve of public issue. He got 35,000 drafts made from the same branch of a nationalised bank in fictitious names as subscribers to the public issue which came to the notice of the court. Fast forward to 2016.
Shouldn’t a bank official in similar circumstances tip off the authorities under the benami law?
Apart from officials of banks and other authorities eminently in a position to smell fish and tip off, the public at large should also be encouraged to participate in this crusade. If VP Singh in his avatar as finance minister found it expedient to reward the excise and customs officials with commission for netting tax evaders, there is a stronger case for rewarding members of public for making bold to finger a benami property holderor the real owner.
VP Singh squelched the moral issue involved by likening it to commission to sales personnel in an organisation. With public however there is no moral issue involved.
First they cannot be expected to tip off as a labour of love. They need to be motivated and the best motivation is offered by money. Second, it is the local public, as it were, that comes to know about the shenanigans of the real owners and their cats paw, the benamidars.
Protect whistleblowers
Equally important is whistleblower protection. Those offering tips must be protected either under the witness protection or whistleblower protection laws perpetually in the making or under a special regime under the benami transactions law itself.
It is all the more reason why members of public must be protected from reprisals. Officials before whom the tipsters unburden must be sworn to oath of secrecy at the pain of punitive action both for singing like a canary and leaking the valuable information on the sly. And yes, since the tips are given sub-rosa, the reward must also be given sub-rosa i.e. in cash.
There are people who bristle with self-righteous indignation even at the hint of commission as inducement.
But the scourge of black money and its concomitant, the benami holdings, cannot be tamed unless the public at large is incentivised to come out with the information in their possession. Employees honest and disgruntled, current or past often are ideally placed to finger the deviants.
The writer is a Delhi-based chartered accountant
IATA’s mobile application will allow travellers to store and manage certifications for Covid-19 tests or ...
A 2010 Act to regulate the medical sector flounders in implementation, even as healthcare remains ...
The scheme to boost local medtech manufacturing is timely, especially given the raging pandemic. But ...
Do pilots sleep on their job?
Fiscal stimulus, friendly monetary policy and firm commodity prices point towards normalcy, says the MD and ...
Price correction is a good opportunity for long-term investors to take the plunge
Q4 earnings, along with progress in controlling Covid-19 spread, will be in focus
Do keep in mind that premium may go up in case one of the members has a pre-existing condition
In an age of falling female workforce participation, worsened by the Covid-19 pandemic, policy makers and ...
Of an injured baby goat, young men on motorcycles and political tensions
It’s the birthday of Muttiah Muralitharan — the man who took a staggering 800 test wickets. What better way to ...
An ode to writer and great-uncle Ved Mehta, and Ekarat, the friend who wrote and quit on his own terms
Monotype’s 2021 type trends report points to a return to hand and the familiar
As ‘ear-points’ between a company and a customer grow, we are witnessing a rise in audio assets
‘Desi Twitter challenger’ Koo on connecting like-minded folks
Coca-Cola has just introduced an oat milk line in the US under its Simply brand. Smart move, say industry ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor