TVS’s Apaches now BS-VI compliant and better equipped
Sometime last year when TVS sent out the four-valve 160 for a ride, it was immediately impressive. From the ...
A pledge is the transfer of goods as security for the payment of debt or performance of a promise - Getty Images/iStockphoto
It was recently reported that a leading depository participant (DP) has misused the Power of Attorney provided by clients and pledged the clients’ shares with banks without their authorisation. As directed by the Securities and Exchange Board of India, some of these unauthorised pledges have been reversed. However, reports say that the banks have sought ownership of the pledged shares.
While SEBI is reviewing a large number of complaints from said clients for misuse of securities and unauthorised pledging of shares, another stockbroker has also come under scanner for similar charges. It is quite possible that more complaints may trickle in, as there seems to be a lack of effective control in this area by SEBI and the Reserve Bank of India.
Analysing the modus operandi suggests that though the culprit may be the DPs, there seems to be negligence on the part of financing banks. The basic tenet of ‘who can create a charge’ appears to have been ignored by the financing banks.
Banks do take securities for loans and advances, and generally, the charge is created by way of pledges, hypothecation, mortgages and assignments. Mortgages are created for immovable properties, while an assignment is made wherever there is an actionable claim, such as life insurance policies, fixed deposits etc. A pledge or hypothecation is applicable for movable goods.
Section 172 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 gives us the definition of a pledge. It states that the bailment — or transfer — of goods as security for payment of a debt or performance of a promise is called a ‘pledge’. For all practical purposes, shares or share certificates are also treated as goods here.
Although charge on a company share can be created by way of pledge or hypothecation for dematerialised securities, banks practically allow only pledge of shares.
There are some basic conditions for creation of valid pledge. A pledge has to be created only by the owner or his authorised agent; and in some cases, by a mercantile agent. Pledging of shares by the DP without authorisation cannot be considered valid, and hence the financing banks cannot make a claim over the securities.
When the DP is holding shares under a demat account, it acts only as a trustee — it must take care of such shares diligently and cannot part with them. The scenario here is unlike that in a bank, where depositors’ money can be lent.
Only in the case of negotiable instruments — like cheques, bills of exchange or promissory notes — can the transferee acquire title over the instrument even if the transferor’s title is defective, provided there is proper consideration and the transaction is done in good faith without negligence. This is not applicable for shares transferred from demat accounts to the banks. When the DP does not own the shares, it cannot pass on any title/ownership to the banks.
In the absence of valid pledge, the banks cannot make any claim over the securities.
In the ongoing cases, banks should have verified who is the owner of the shares before accepting the shares as security. There seems to be negligence on their part here.
However, banks generally take insurance coverage for frauds perpetrated on them. If a DP has defrauded the banks, they can make a claim with the insurance company as per policy terms. Criminal action should also be initiated against the fraudster.
The writer is a retired banker
Sometime last year when TVS sent out the four-valve 160 for a ride, it was immediately impressive. From the ...
Tata Motors‘ new premium hatch will bring a breath of fresh air to the segment and make you rethink the ...
Often, customers come for an entry-level bike, but drive away a 200 or 250
Along with 390 Adventure, the KTM network will be buzzing with activity from next month
Tightening of presumptive taxation norms under Sec 44 AD, 44 ADA may be on the cards
Regular investments, emergency reserves, adequate insurance and plugging gaps can do the trick
India will soon join the rest of the world in the shift towards passive investing, says Margaret Franklin
While there is a correlation, one does not lead to the other
The Transgender Bill 2019 has let down the very people it intends to protect and help
It has become standard practice to blame epochal events in history for actions taken today
Why the erosion of public universities — vital learning spaces that are not only accessible to the ...
The World Health Organization estimates that depression and anxiety — among the more prominent mental health ...
Reflections on ten big consumer trends that dominated the past decade
There is a shift in the way Marriott is looking at delivering luxurious experiences to its guests
Kerala wants to be India’s creative hub where designers ideate, imagine and innovate for tomorrow
How Fujifilm has used its imaging strength to re-invent itself
With land and State resources in short supply, only higher education can challenge social hierarchies, says ...
Fee hike can hit students of low-income groups
The fees for the flagship Post Graduate Programme (PGP) in Management at the Indian Institute of ...
Farmers, reeling under crop losses, feel the Centre’s crop insurance scheme is merely helping insurance firms ...