Beware the quantum computers
Today’s encryption technology will be putty in the hands of those running the post-quantum world. How equipped ...
‘Democratic dynasties’?
It’s a term deployed by Kanchan Chandra, professor of politics at NYU and lead author of the book, Democratic Dynasties: State, Party and Family in Contemporary Indian Politics. Chandra notes that dynastic politics is presumed to be the “antithesis” of democracy, but is in fact a routine aspect of politics in many modern democracies. They are a modern phenomenon, distinguished from traditional aristocracies in that they depend on electoral endorsement.
In the way Rahul Gandhi was the sole candidate for party presidentship?
Sort of, but more generally, in the way political dynasties seek electoral validation.
So this phenomenon isn’t peculiar to India?
Not at all. As the Bushes, the Kennedys, the Clintons, the Bhuttos, the Abes, the Lees and, nearer home, the Nehru-Gandhis establish, many countries around the world have ‘democratic dynasties’. There are other examples from Brazil and the Philippines. Even non-democratic political systems have political dynasties: notably the Kims of North Korea.
Right. So how do ‘democratic dynasties’ perform?
Not very well. Researchers Siddharth George at Harvard University and Dominic Ponattu at the University of Mannheim, Germany, note in a 2017 paper, ‘Understanding the economic impacts of political dynasties: evidence from India’, that “dynasties are in general bad for economic development”.
How does one account for that?
Economic theory holds that dynastic politicians may be encouraged to invest more in their constituencies. But, in fact, they may be more motivated to cultivate “clientelistic” relationships and foster loyal “vote banks”. Second, while dynasts may theoretically have stronger incentives to govern well, they are insulated from competition to the extent that performance incentives are muted.
Why should that be?
George and Ponattu postulate that dynasts may exert lower efforts because they are insured against political failure by familial control of the party. “Even if they perform poorly, their family members may use their clout to ensure they get a party ticket,” the researchers add. In the long run, this may even corrode democracy.
How so?
Because potential challengers may be deterred: it is hard to believe that in a truly open contest, not even one person may want to contest Rahul Gandhi’s candidature. Dynastic rule has a chilling effect on political competition, which could worsen accountability and governance.
How do other countries fare?
Again, not so well. In the Philippines, for instance, 70 per cent of parliamentarians are dynasts: and, according to a 2016 study by scholars Ronald Mendoza, Edsel Beja Jr, Victor Venida and David Yap at the Asian Institute of Management, found “a worsening effect of political dynasties on poverty” — constituencies represented by dynasts tended to have more poverty and higher income inequality. A similar study of Brazil in 2015 by economists Arthur Braganca at UFMG, Claudio Ferraz at PUC-Rio and Juan Rios at Stanford University established that dynasties cause government performance to deteriorate, leading to larger governments with no significant gains in economic performance or public goods provision.
The bottomline?
Political dynasties make for bad economics and rotten development.
A weekly column that helps you ask the right questions
Today’s encryption technology will be putty in the hands of those running the post-quantum world. How equipped ...
Rocketship’s Anand Rajaraman on getting pitches from places like Rameswaram and Patna
Bengaluru-based Archeron group plans to open five banks that are run entirely by AI and quantum technologies
Ably skippered by N Srinivasan, India Cements is upping its post-Covid-19 game by expanding capacity
Three-in-one: Passive debt funds come at a low cost and have high-quality portfolios. Some offer return ...
Trend in the rupee movement and Q4 earnings can give direction to the market
There is room for improvement in fund transfer options
Silver looks positive but lacks the higher volumes required to substantiate bullishness
In an age of falling female workforce participation, worsened by the Covid-19 pandemic, policy makers and ...
Murder is a theme that is unlikely to darken and yellow with time, the writer Truman Capote had once said.
Expect the unexpected when musicians of different traditions come together for a duet
On Ugadi, the Telugu New Year Day, a chronicler recalls slices of an isolated year gone by and realises that ...
Marketers are padded up, sponsorship deals have been struck, and campaigns are rolling out. Now let the games ...
And what marketers can possibly do to bring it back in our lives
The agency has changed form over the years but its lustre has not dimmed
Media Factory has purchased the majority stake held by Sam and Lara Balsara of Madison World in Madison Media ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor