Bonjour, new guests from small-town India
Puneet Dhawan of Accor is brimming with ideas on ways to revive the hospitality sector
Why would foreign direct investors come to an India where white collar criminals can cheat banks and individuals with impunity? And why is it that investigative agencies and the courts treat such fraudsters with kid gloves? Until we get serious about such crony capitalism, our economy will continue to plod canter instead of galloping.
An article on the website squarefeetindia.com says that Rakesh Wadhawan, of HDIL, who is a wilful defaulter of PMC Bank, had, a few months prior to the PMC Bank scam being revealed, gifted their house to a private family trust, in an effort to ring fence it from attachment. Presuming that the Wadhawans had given personal guarantees, this seems a fraudulent attempt to sequester personal assets and so reduce the collateral for the bank. Meanwhile, the depositors of the bank continue to suffer a freeze on their deposits.
Twisting the knife in the depositor’s wound, the RBI explained why a rescue of PMC Bank is not possible, unlike failed private bank, YES Bank, where it was. RBI said that YES Bank was a corporate entity where voting was based on the number of shares held, one vote per share. But in a co-operative bank like PMC, voting is based on one vote per member, irrespective of holding. To me, that seems like a cop out. Possibly, RBI felt rescuing one co operative bank would set a precedent for others, and there are far too many co-op banks that have been criminally negligent in lending depositor money.
Adding salt to depositors bloody injury, the article also states that, so long as the banking licence is not cancelled, depositors cannot claim deposit insurance of ₹5 lakh from the Deposit Insurance & Credit Guarantee Corporation! It is RBI that decides when to cancel the licence. So, even the deposit insurance is denied.
Savers and depositors are modern day slaves. Their savings are kept in a bank, whose officials either through oversight or through collusion, give loans to white collar criminals who have no intention to repay. In the case of PMC as much as 74 per cent of deposit funds was loaned to HDIL group. That, in itself, is enough of improper management to warrant a cancellation of its licence! Why doesn’t it?
This reminds one of the old song, Sixteen Tons, about coal miners toiling in underground mines:
You load sixteen tons, what do you get? Another day older and deeper in debt; Saint Peter don't you call me 'cause I can't go; I owe my soul to the company store.
In another bizarre move, the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) sought to lay a claim on Reliance Jio for the past liabilities, due on AGR (Adjusted Gross Revenue) of Reliance Communications, with which Jio had a spectrum sharing arrangement. DoT wanted to claim its dues owed by RComm from Jio even prior to the arrangement!
Is this an attraction for FDI? If a company invests in India, it will have to deal with other companies. Suppose it buys, let’s say, coal from another company. Would it become liable for past dues of the supplier, on unpaid royalty on coal? Can business be done in this manner?
Now, the DoT has objected to the settlement of the resolution plan proposed by the Committee of Creditors, for liquidation of bankrupt RComm, under which ₹23,000 crore would flow in, and be used to settle dues of RComm. DoT is an operational creditor, who is unsecured, and, as such, ranks below a secured creditor. This is a globally accepted norm. DoT complains that it will recover much less than secured creditors and wants the distribution to be reviewed.
But if we keep trying to reinvent the wheel, the car will never move forward!
The same point was debated in the Essar Steel case and it was decided, rightly, that secured creditors had superior rights.
Is this continuous reinventing of the wheel an attraction for FDI?
The writer is India Head-Finance,Asia,Haymarket.The views are personal
Puneet Dhawan of Accor is brimming with ideas on ways to revive the hospitality sector
Citroen’s first vehicle sports a novel design and European interiors. It is also meant to be as comfortable as ...
The pandemic is only the tip of the iceberg that the country’s cash-poor airlines — both regional and national ...
The government is yet to specify the framework of its recently announced old vehicle scrappage policy
This Women’s Day, we discuss the features of a few financial products that aim to help you save, get insured ...
Sensex, Nifty 50 make a strong bounce-back, but test resistances
Avenue Supermarts (₹3,286.1): Makes fresh all-time highIn October last year, the stock of Avenue Supermarts ...
The exchange-traded fund ticks all boxes as an efficient tool to track gold prices
They are the health warriors who battled the Covid-19 pandemic on the ground, and are now the face of the ...
Uzbekistan’s grandest city dazzles tourists with its history, architecture and food
It’s the birth anniversary of Michelangelo di Lodovico Buonarroti Simoni, one of the great artists and ...
Reading in the loo — flipping through anything, really — appears to help the locomotion
Its name is the starting point of a brand’s journey and can make a big difference in the success sweepstakes
Sober spirits are the in thing
A peek into where ad spends went last year and where they are headed tomorrow
Can Swiggy Instamart disrupt the ecommerce groceries space, currently ruled by the Amazons and Big Baskets? ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor