Modi – the middle class hero

Rasheeda Bhagat
Comment (10)   ·   print   ·  
Narendra Modi
Narendra Modi

Over a sumptuous round of chakris (a Gujarati form of melting-soft murrukkus), mathiya (a Diwali speciality that looks a lot like fried papad), other savouries and a wide variety of sweets, we are gathered in the house of a Gujarati businessman in Ahmedabad.

The occasion, a Diwali get-together, is an excellent opportunity to gauge the mood of this group – actually a no-brainer – about Narendra Modi and his development model in Gujarat and his prospects in the Assembly elections for which voting begins in three weeks.

Bela Bhagat, a primary school teacher, married to Baiju Bhagat a successful lawyer, is the most vocal fan of Modi in the group. She moved to Ahmedabad about 12 years ago from her home town of Kolkata after her marriage. “Within five years I could see visible development happening in Ahmedabad and in the rest of Gujarat. And it is in such sharp contrast to my home city of Kolkata.”

Incidentally, Modi has been Chief Minister of Gujarat for around the same period – from 2001 till today.

“Will Modi become CM again? Of course, that is absolutely certain. But where we want to see him is in Delhi – as the Prime Minister of India.. I’d say he is on the threshold of doing that,” she gushes. Others in the group nod appreciatively as she adds: “This summer I went to Kolkata and was shocked to see no development has taken place. If the Left was bad, Mamata has done nothing either. Today Ahmedabad is the best city to live in India.”

Bharat Jani, a manufacturer of anti-corrosive cement, is all smiles as he says that Modi will sweep the elections. “He is the best CM in India, from the state of the roads, the flyovers, health care facilities to the ease of doing business, he has brought around overall development.”

A couple of young women in the group say Ahmedabad is the safest city in the world, and a woman can be out late in the evenings without any problem. The nonchalance with which the 2002 riots are brushed aside is shocking. There are only murmurs, even though uncomfortable, about “that is in the past and should be forgotten”. Only Baiju admits that a non-secular label is not a good one for Gujarat to have, but he is most happy about life in Modi raj.

When I repeat the crux of this dialogue to social scientist and human rights activist Achyut Yagnic, chief of Centre for Social Knowledge and Action, he grins and says: “Oh yes, this is Gujarati parochialism to the fore. The Gujarati middle class, specially the urbanites, are all for Modi”.

So isn’t there going to be a wave for Modi’s BJP, I ask him.

“What I see around me in not a wave. Yes, what we do have is a wave of publicity but then Modi is a master propagandist.”

Yagnik has no doubt that the BJP led by Modi will emerge victorious, but he is certain its numbers will come down. “Improve upon its present 121 seats? That is out of the question. In a house of 182, 92 seats are required for a simple majority. Even the inner circles in the BJP say they will get around 105 seats and not more.”

The reason why Modi is headed for a third victory, says Yagnic, is simple. According to the 11th Census, the urbanisation in Gujarat is 43 per cent, compared to the average of 32 per cent in India. “The urbanites in Gujarat love him, and the entire middle class of Gujarat is with him, so it will be easy for him to win,” he says. “But this time the Congress is much more active and aggressive and I think the factionalism and inner fighting in the party has also come down.. so it will do better than in 2007,” is his verdict.

But J.V.Momin, an AICC delegate and former general secretary and ex-vice president of the Gujarat Congress, disagrees. “Infighting continues and there are so many groups within our party. We will improve upon our present number of 53 MLAs, but not by much. That is the sad truth.”

Surprisingly candid, he says unfortunately over the years Congress has allowed its traditional vote banks – Muslims, Dalits, ST and SC – to move away from it. On Muslim candidates, he says he has asked for 11 tickets “but we are likely to get only seven seats. With great agony and as a senior Muslim leader, I say that we are not satisfied with this decision. Last time the Congress fielded six Muslim candidates and five of them won.”

(To be continued)

(This article was published on November 17, 2012)
XThese are links to The Hindu Business Line suggested by Outbrain, which may or may not be relevant to the other content on this page. You can read Outbrain's privacy and cookie policy here.


Rasheeda Bhagat, the name itself speaks for itself. You need not read the article

from:  Kartheek
Posted on: Nov 17, 2012 at 18:56 IST

Congress has allowed its traditional vote banks – Muslims, Dalits, ST and SC – to move away from it. On Muslim candidates, he says he has asked for 11 tickets “but we are likely to get only 7 seats. With great agony and as a senior Muslim leader I say that we are not satisfied with this decision. Last time the Congress fielded 6 Muslim candidates and five of them won.”

as long as Congress is going to look at Communities like the above, Congress is doomed in a resurgent / young India.

from:  pvnatarajan
Posted on: Nov 17, 2012 at 19:22 IST

He is the best CM indeed and Well will do our all best to make him the
Prime Minister. Next Stop is Dilli Modi ji.

from:  Rachit
Posted on: Nov 17, 2012 at 20:18 IST

People of Gujarat thank him for wiping out the Most corrupt politicians
from Gujarat..... now Congis are taking the help of a dead politician
keshubhai to make an entry .....

from:  KPS
Posted on: Nov 17, 2012 at 20:43 IST

How the hell this Achyut Yagnic say "Gujarati parochialism"?? He should be sued for using such darogatory words for all Gujaratis. I bet Gujarati middle class is more inclusive than any other average Indian in their journey of development.

from:  parag shah
Posted on: Nov 18, 2012 at 01:22 IST

On three important social indicators, viz life expectancy at birth
(LEB), mean years of schooling (MYS) and school life expectancy (SLE),
Gujarat is far behind some other states. In Gujarat, the LEB during
2002-06 was 64.1 years and it ranked ninth among major Indian states. In
the areas of MYS and SLE, during 2004-05, it ranked seventh and ninth,
respectively. Kerala ranked first in all three indicators. Even
Maharashtra, Himachal Pradesh, Punjab, Haryana, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka
performed much better than Gujarat.

from:  naresh
Posted on: Nov 19, 2012 at 15:25 IST

the comments above itself show how parochial and racist modi's voters are. development has taken place in congress ruled states too as well as in gujarat before modi, but its not development which the middle class right wing male /female adores modi for. its the inherent butcher image which makes the middle class go mad for a feuhrer, be it germany, middle east or india.

from:  kroneckerdelta
Posted on: Nov 19, 2012 at 15:35 IST

Only sick/retarded so called liberals like Rasheeda Bhagat keep re-resurrecting the vote bank politics by comments like "traditional vote banks – Muslims, Dalits, ST and SC". Especially in the times when Mr. Modi is tirelessly addressing the state as a state of "6 crore Gujaratis" which includes EVERYBODY. He never addressed state residents as Hindus/Muslims/Jains/Aadivasi etc... Rasheeda, I am ashamed to have you as my Indian sister. Grow up and think beyond self-imposed boundaries.

from:  Deshdaaz
Posted on: Nov 21, 2012 at 00:48 IST

Forget u know lies - ...lies and stats... Modi is a clean man
swimming in the gutter of Indian the dirty guys (which
means nearly all politicians) don't want him - as simple as that.

from:  Vik
Posted on: Nov 22, 2012 at 19:11 IST

It appears the pseudosecularists are frustrated with victorious leader's achievements.The despair of AICC official referred in the article accepting the reality is noteworthy.After all, a party which champions itself in scams & is in denial mode cannot fool the wise Gujarati community. From childhood, the Ahmedabadis in late fifties have witnessed worst riots happening regularly-all of them under Congress rule & who only replaced the CM by another one to prove his credentials by soft pedalling the antisocial elements.One Dy CM then had cosy relationship with lead bootleggar who was subsequently liquidated by a CM who is now a frontline Gujarat Congress leader.

If one pays due weightage to these facts,one would stop condemning Modi who appears to successfully overcome the onslaught of pseudo-secularism third time albeit with a smaller margin to create a path breaking record.There is no doubt ,if given a chance, Modi will prove to be a better PM than the current ineffective & silent PM.

from:  Mr.Frank
Posted on: Nov 24, 2012 at 14:59 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor



Recent Article in Rasheeda Bhagat

The perfect solution. That's what M Yunus found

India lacks a messiah for microcredit

Muhammad Yunus gave Bangladesh’s rural women a voice and transformed the economy. Why can’t it happen here? »

Comments to: Copyright © 2015, The Hindu Business Line.