Travel pass: Pros may outweigh cons
IATA’s mobile application will allow travellers to store and manage certifications for Covid-19 tests or ...
The SEBI’s insider trading regulations prohibit trading in listed securities when in possession of Unpublished Price-Sensitive Information (UPSI). The question here is, what is ‘unpublished’ information.
This was recently examined in the SEBI’s order issued in February 2021 in the matter of Future Retail. In this order, Kishore Biyani and certain other persons were held to have violated the insider trading regulations by purchasing Future Retail’s shares before the announcement of a scheme by Future Retail to hive off its HomeTown and FabFurnish businesses. The announcement had a positive impact on Future Retail’s share price.
Biyani’s side argued that such information was not “unpublished” since it had already been reported in the media. They cited an interview in which Biyani had stated that Future Retail planned to exit several specialty retail formats including HomeTown. Rejecting this argument, the SEBI held that the level of detail reported in the media was significantly lesser than the information in Future Retail’s formal announcement, which included the proposed share-swap ratio, details of securities to be issued, and other particulars. This is not a new issue.
In one of the early cases under the 1992 Insider Trading Regulations, Hindustan Lever was investigated for purchasing shares of Brooke Bond Lipton India in the period leading up to the announcement of a merger between the two companies in 1996. Although the SEBI concluded that there was a violation under the 1992 Insider Trading Regulations, the Appellate Authority held that the SEBI was not justified in prosecuting Hindustan Lever since expectations of the merger were widespread in the market. Following this decision, an explanation was added to the 1992 Regulations in 2002 stating that “speculative reports in print or electronic media shall not be considered as published information.”
Subsequently, the 1992 Regulations were replaced in 2015. Under the 2015 Regulations (which are currently in force) information is considered unpublished when it is not “generally available”. “Generally available information” is defined as “information that is accessible to the public on a non-discriminatory basis”. Notably, the explanation under the 1992 Regulations (as amended in 2002) did not find a place under the 2015 Regulations.
In October 2020, the SEBI took a different view from Future Retail in the Gopal Vittal matter where it relied on availability of information regarding an acquisition in media reports and on news channels as making it generally available in the public domain. The order in the Future Retail matter is sound and unimpeachable since information should be considered “generally available” only when all the material particulars are disclosed. However, the question is whether the current regulations support such a view, particularly when considering that the explanation that was introduced in 2002 has since been left out.
After traversing a full circle, it may be time to put this issue to rest – the explanation regarding speculative reports in print or electronic media not constituting “published information” (which was included in the regulations in 2002 but omitted in 2015) may be a helpful addition. This would be even more relevant in the age of social media where public confidence in the authenticity of media reports may not be at the same level as before.
(The authors are advocates with S&R Associates, a law firm)
IATA’s mobile application will allow travellers to store and manage certifications for Covid-19 tests or ...
A 2010 Act to regulate the medical sector flounders in implementation, even as healthcare remains ...
The scheme to boost local medtech manufacturing is timely, especially given the raging pandemic. But ...
Do pilots sleep on their job?
Fiscal stimulus, friendly monetary policy and firm commodity prices point towards normalcy, says the MD and ...
Price correction is a good opportunity for long-term investors to take the plunge
Q4 earnings, along with progress in controlling Covid-19 spread, will be in focus
Do keep in mind that premium may go up in case one of the members has a pre-existing condition
The hemming in of Mamata Banerjee by the BJP in what was once a Trinamool stronghold sums up the story of West ...
Inside Narayan Chandra Sinha’s universe house, metal and nature’s footprints are churned into an organic whole
A former resident relives sepia-tinted memories of growing up in a hilly, colonial tea range of the Western ...
It starts with the lack of new email messages: A sudden silence from my personal world. It’s a mellow Saturday ...
Monotype’s 2021 type trends report points to a return to hand and the familiar
As ‘ear-points’ between a company and a customer grow, we are witnessing a rise in audio assets
‘Desi Twitter challenger’ Koo on connecting like-minded folks
Coca-Cola has just introduced an oat milk line in the US under its Simply brand. Smart move, say industry ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor