Bonjour, new guests from small-town India
Puneet Dhawan of Accor is brimming with ideas on ways to revive the hospitality sector
India may choose to pursue legal remedies in the Vodafone tax case, but the options may be limited, according to experts.
“It will not be easy for India to challenge this award, primarily, because it was pronounced unanimously by all arbitrators including the one nominated by India,” said Neerav Merchant, Partner, Majmudar & Partners.
The International Arbitration Tribunal at The Hague last week ruled in favour of British telecom major Vodafone Group Plc and said India must stop seeking dues from the company and, in fact, pay it over ₹40 crore as partial compensation for legal costs. The tax department should also refund about ₹45 crore that was collected as tax from Vodafone.
The Finance Ministry in a statement had said the government would take a decision on the further course of action including legal remedies before appropriate fora.
“If India wants to challenge the award, it can do so before the court of the seat of arbitration on the grounds of lack of substantive jurisdiction or serious procedural irregularity. But taking either of these grounds seems an adventurous task. Alternatively, India might be preparing to raise objections, including that of public policy, when Vodafone brings the award for enforcement,” Merchant further said.
Sandeep Jhunjhunwala, Partner, Nangia Andersen LLP, noted that India has two options — either to accept and pay the arbitration award or to contest it before the Singapore High Court, which is the seat of arbitration under the India-Netherlands Bilateral Investment Treaty.
“Banking on public policy of India, the government would certainly contest the concurrence with the latest arbitral award on the retrospective tax in favour of Vodafone Plc. Retrospective tax, in this case, clearly qualifies to be public policy of the country since the house of law makers — that is, Parliament — had given its consent to the legislative amendments that introduced this tax, making it a law of the country,” he noted.
The case will also have significant repercussion on other similar cases such as the tax dispute with Cairn Energy.
Experts noted that while a foot-dragging approach has customarily been taken towards the enforcement of international arbitral awards on the argument of violation of public policy of the country, the government should this time consider accepting the decision and using it as an opportunity to attract investments.
“The BALCO versus Kaiser Aluminium case in September 2012, followed by significant amendments to the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, on December 31, 2015, was a sincere attempt by the legislature to restrict award-debtors from abusing the court process and or to obstruct the smooth enforcement of foreign awards in Indian courts. India is a signatory to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, and this fact should also extend to the Vodafone award, notwithstanding that the award is pronounced under Bilateral Treaty Investment,” Merchant noted.
“Defying such arbitral awards would unquestionably attract international pressure on the country’s international investment and foreign affairs strategy asking the authorities to re-evaluate their stand,” Jhunjhunwala said.
Puneet Dhawan of Accor is brimming with ideas on ways to revive the hospitality sector
Citroen’s first vehicle sports a novel design and European interiors. It is also meant to be as comfortable as ...
The pandemic is only the tip of the iceberg that the country’s cash-poor airlines — both regional and national ...
The government is yet to specify the framework of its recently announced old vehicle scrappage policy
Here is a checklist that equips you to discern the market nuances
Sensex, Nifty 50 have witnessed sharp decline
The fund has consistently outperformed S&P BSE 100 TRI over one, three and five years
Returns are superior to immediate annuity plans, but SCSS can secure better rates for new investors sooner if ...
With the public looking beyond mainstream media for reports from the ground, independent digital platforms are ...
* From March to September for a period of 28 weeks the Atlantis ballroom was turned into an artist’s studio ...
A book on Badri Narayan is a tribute — albeit a belated one — to an artist who did not enjoy the recognition ...
The country hasn’t had a quiet moment since the military seized power on February 1
Its name is the starting point of a brand’s journey and can make a big difference in the success sweepstakes
Sober spirits are the in thing
A peek into where ad spends went last year and where they are headed tomorrow
Can Swiggy Instamart disrupt the ecommerce groceries space, currently ruled by the Amazons and Big Baskets? ...
Three years after its inception, compliance with GST procedures remains a headache for exporters, job workers ...
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives of companies are altering the prospects for wooden toys of ...
Aequs Aerospace to create space for large-scale manufacture of toys at Koppal
And it has every reason to smile. Covid-19 has triggered a consumer shift towards branded products as ...
Please Email the Editor