India’s ambition of creating renewable energy capacity of 500 GW by 2030 cannot be realised without large-scale storage systems. It is generally accepted that conventional battery systems cannot provide an affordable solution. In the search for alternatives, one bright candidate has been the ‘flow battery’, which is modular and hence easily scalable.
As detailed earlier in these columns, in flow batteries, energy is stored in two liquid electrolytes in separate tanks. When you charge, the energy supplied urges electrons from the electron-poor side to move to the electron-rich side — like taking water uphill — creating a potential difference. During discharge, the reverse happens — electrons flow from the electron-rich side to the electron-poor side. (The flow of electrons is electricity. Gaining electrons is a ‘reduction reaction’, losing electrons is ‘oxidation’, hence ‘redox’.) The conversion of energy from chemical to electrical happens in a cell, which is split into two half-cells by a membrane. Of course, you need electrolytes that are electron-rich and electron-poor to start with — that is the science of preparing electrolytes. Usually, vanadium is used as an electrolyte, as the metal exists as four ionic species — with two, three, four or five (positively charged) protons more than the number of (negatively charged) electrons.
Flow batteries bring some significant advantages. First, they are modular — you can keep increasing the energy storage capacity by simply raising the volume of the electrolyte tanks. If you want more power, you only need to increase the number of membrane stacks. The separation of storage capacity and power is a notable advantage. RP Deshpande, an expert, has compared this to an internal combustion engine in cars. The size of the engine determines the power; if the manufacturer wants the car to go a longer distance in one fuel-fill, he only has to increase the fuel tank size.
Diesel-petrol combo engineHow to increase engine efficiency at higher loads, while also cutting emissions
Second, they can store power for long durations, which is significant to the seasonal wind industry. Giant tanks can hold large amounts of electrolytes to store more energy. However, the big hurdle to vanadium redox batteries has been the high cost of vanadium, which accounts for more than a third of the system cost.
But now, Prof Kothandaraman Ramanujam of IIT-Madras has developed a flow battery based on lead. Ramanujam tells Quantum that the battery has been found to work well and is market-ready.
The use of lead in energy storage is age-old; the lead-acid batteries are ubiquitous. The world knows how to handle lead.
Furthermore, the metal is cheap and available in India.
Solid-state batteries can stop EVs catching fireThe move away from liquid electrolytes, which are highly flammable organic solvents
So, what was holding back lead redox flow batteries? Ramanujam says that in the ‘soluble lead redox flow batteries’, the big challenge was the growth of dendrites, which are filament-like spikes, or extrusions, that could create short-circuit by connecting the two electrodes and giving the electrons a less-resistance pathway.
Ramanujam’s team has been able to “successfully circumvent” the dendrite growth problem. “Using additives, dendrite growth has been mitigated up to 50 mAh per sq cm of areal capacity, when the battery was cycled at 50 mA per sq cm of current density. The achieved capacity is nearly five times that of lead-acid batteries,” Ramanujam said. The battery has been tested for over 500 charge-discharge cycles. Ramanujam is looking for funding for a pilot plant.
Is this the breakthrough the industry is waiting for? It looks like it, but only a pilot plant can give a clearer picture. The flow battery technology is being sharpened elsewhere in the world, too. Vanadium, the active material for storing energy, has been sought to be replaced with iron (Yang Shi, The Chinese University of Hong Kong), manganese (Prof Ingo Krossing, University of Freiburg), and manganese and sulphur (Dr Barun Chakrabarti, University of Warwick). Just as there are multiple chemistries of lithium-ion batteries, there is perhaps an application-based role for all of these emerging technologies.
“Flow batteries are in early-commercialisation phase and just starting the manufacturing scale-up,” says Dr Rahul Walawalkar, Founder and President, Indian Energy Storage Alliance, and Chair for the Global Energy Storage Alliance, adding, “We do anticipate that flow batteries will be a key part of the solution mix as we move towards net zero.” Walawalkar, however, cautions against too much focus on cost reduction while ignoring other factors such as round-trip efficiency.